19 Neighbors is a series of 19 stories about Western Pennsylvanians and how they are helping, hoping and coping during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The first thing a visitor to Jamie McElroy and Justin Schwartzmiller’s house sees is shoes. Dozens of shoes.
In the living room, there are at least 15 pairs ranging from black-and-white Vans to day-glo New Balance to Adidas soccer shoes, all neatly lined up next to a silver radiator. It’s a fraction of the total collection of this pair of self-described sneaker bums.
But one of the shoes they can’t wait to fill fits in Mr. Schwartzmiller’s palm: an infant-sized retro Air Jordan.
That’s for their daughter, who is expected in mid-August, just a few weeks after they celebrate a year together in their home, a 120-year-old frame house on Arlington Avenue in the city neighborhood of the same name.
“August 17th — same day as Robert De Niro,” said Ms. McElroy, a bartender and waitress prone to quoting the movie “Goodfellas.”
Read More
It has been a trying time for them — and unfathomably awful for many others — but the couple concede there was one good thing about 2020: It prodded them to make some life-changing decisions.
“Oh, absolutely,” Mr. Schwartzmiller said.
“I feel like the universe kind of kicks you through doors when you’re not making the moves yourself,” Ms. McElroy said. “In a lot of ways we were to take the next step, but we just didn’t for whatever reason. It wasn’t until the pandemic and everything really slowed down that we were able to say, ‘Yes, this is what we want,’ to take a clear look at it.”
When COVID-19 struck the region last spring, they were among a handful of couples profiled by the Post-Gazette on how the pandemic quarantine had affected their relationships.

They had been together for several years and lived close by, but apart, on the South Side. The restaurant where Ms. McElroy worked closed immediately and has remained so since March.
As a union driver for Talon Logistics, the trucking arm of Giant Eagle, Mr. Schwartzmiller found his everyday work given new appreciation as a front-line occupation, a vital spoke in the supply chain that was pushed to the limit in the pandemic’s early days, as shortages of meat and personal care products became commonplace.
He was working almost nonstop and constantly interacting with co-workers and warehouses and stores. With so much unknown about how the coronavirus spread, they severely curtailed contact with each other. He’d swing by the alley house where she lived with her mother, who had pre-existing conditions, on his way home, and she would bring him a hot plate of food for dinner.
“Edwards Way Grubhub,” she quipped at the time.
“There was nothing to do for me but to work, so I just went to work six and seven days a week and put money away and was able to put a nice down payment on a house,” he said.
“We really missed each other,” she said. “He’s my best friend. It was really hard being away from each other. When you see someone you love every single day for years and then you can’t, that was really hard. It made us want to be together.”
They did not have to look far to see how the pandemic has upended relationships.
Ms. McElroy’s sister, Lauren, 35, is a Pittsburgh Public Schools teacher and a swim coach at Brashear High School. A former Army reservist, she was deployed in Kuwait in 2015 when she met an Italian air force pilot while finishing a 3,000-meter swim at the base pool.
That chance interaction began a multiyear trans-Atlantic romance between Sgt. McElroy and Maj. Marco Ricco that culminated in their 2019 marriage in Frosinone, an ancient town less than 50 miles south of Rome. After an Italian honeymoon, she returned to the U.S. The couple last saw each other on Dec. 27, 2019, when he went back to Italy after spending Christmas in Pittsburgh. She was supposed to visit Italy last April and move to Rome with him last summer.
Travel restrictions and quarantine requirements in both the United States and Italy made that logistically impossible because of the time and money involved. Lauren McElroy signed on to teach another year for PPS and will finally, at long last, move to Italy, likely in June.
She’s glad to have had this extra time with her family, especially with Jamie pregnant. Teaching has kept her more than occupied — “Everything about online teaching has five more steps to it than in person,” she said — as has preparing for a new life abroad.
She and Marco have an apartment waiting for them in Ciampino, a suburb about 20 minutes south of Rome, and it’ll be their first time living together despite having been married for nearly two years.
“That’s our strength, is our ability to communicate because we’ve always been long distance. We’re sick of it, we’re over it, but there’s still not much we can control, so let’s not get upset about that and just deal with what we can control.”
“If we had to write letters, that would have made it very difficult,” she laughed. They don’t write letters, but she’s sent a lot of greeting cards, which apparently aren’t a thing over there.
“There’s a greater perspective though, that we’ve been privileged to have had constant employment, to not be hungry, to not be sick. We have our own struggles, but others have struggled worse,” she said, but added, “Being stuck alone with my husband would’ve been nice.”
“I do cry about sometimes, and I’m like damn, this ... sucks.”
Her sister and Mr. Schwartzmiller are the first to admit their good fortune, despite the chaos of the world at large.
“It all just kind of worked out, and the universe said, ‘Here, here’s your place,’ and we started to nest, and the next thing you know, we got a baby on the way, like it was all so logical,” Jamie McElroy said. “But it’s completely illogical because there’s a pandemic going on.”
“As much of a messed up year that it was, it was probably one of the best years of my life,” he said. “For so many people out there it’s so bad. And it was for a little while in a certain sense but ...”
They responded nearly in unison: “We’re so lucky.”
Lucky for him to have been able to work uninterrupted. For them to be able to eat dinner together, a rarity when they were both employed. To work out together and get healthier. The two longtime smokers both quit.
“We wouldn’t be having this baby if we didn’t have that time to take care of ourselves. There’s no doubt in my mind,” she said.
Those baby Jordans — which match a pair that Mr. Schwartzmiller owns — arrived the day that the expectant parents were scheduled to get the results of the baby’s genetic testing. They took it as a good omen, and it was. Ms. McElroy is 40 and at higher risk for pregnancy complications, but she got the proverbial clean bill.
The pandemic continues. But so does their life together.
“That pause in life really does make you look around and go, ‘What’s going on here? What’s important, what’s not important. … Hey, what’s important here, hon?” she said in a deliberately thick Pittsburgh accent.
“You just kinda look around and go, ‘I’m gonna hold tight to the stuff that’s good, and the stuff that’s not is just gonna fall away. And I did, and it does.”
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.