Capping a roughly three-and-a-half-year ordeal, Alex Hribal is expected to plead guilty Tuesday to stabbing or cutting 20 students and a security guard at Franklin Regional High School in 2014.

His attorney, Patrick Thomassey, told Westmoreland County Common Pleas Judge Christopher Feliciani of his plans Monday, a staffer in the judge’s office said. Mr. Thomassey didn't return messages, but he had been expected to alert the court of Mr. Hribal's intentions following a pretrial hearing Friday.

Mr. Hribal, who turned 20 this month, is charged with 21 counts each of attempted homicide and aggravated assault in the April 9, 2014, attack. Four students were critically injured, but everyone survived.

How long Mr. Hribal will spend in prison will remain an open question even after he enters the plea; Judge Feliciani will sentence him at a separate hearing that hasn't been scheduled.

Advertise with us

The maximum sentence for the attempted homicide charges is between 20 and 40 years. The defense rejected a plea deal last year that offered between 30 and 60 years, said Westmoreland County district attorney John Peck.

"I think his age and his mental condition arguably could reduce the sentence" from the maximum, Mr. Peck said. "But on the other hand, there are many victims and families who sustained enormous suffering as a result of what he did."

That morning, authorities said Mr. Hribal brought a pair of kitchen knives from home to Franklin Regional and began slashing students in a first-floor hallway before classes started. Just three days earlier, he had written a rambling manifesto on lined notebook paper in which he extolled the Columbine massacre perpetrators and taunted fellow students. Police found it in his backpack.

Though no one disputes that he carried out the rampage, the case has been mired in legal hurdles from the beginning.

Mr. Thomassey sought to move it from adult to juvenile court, where, if found responsible for the crimes, Mr Hribal would have been released from custody at 21. Judge Feliciani denied the request in May 2016, saying "the risk of the defendant's relapse, potential for re-offending in a similar manner, now, or upon his release ... and many unknown and unpredictable psychological/psychiatric factors ... outweigh the likelihood that the defendant's re-entry into our community would be safe and of no concern to the community."

Advertise with us

The judge in February rejected Mr. Thomassey's request to enter a guilty but mentally ill plea for Mr. Hribal, a distinction that would have meant prison time only if his condition improved with treatment first at a mental health facility. He wrote in his decision that while Mr. Hribal "may have suffered from a psychotic illness," it "did not cause him to substantially lack the capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of his conduct ..."

The case has presented a number of thorny legal issues, said Bruce Antkowiak, a law professor at Saint Vincent College and former federal prosecutor who has watched its developments, especially the "real dichotomy between the juvenile and adult systems."

"Try as our prison system will" to provide needed psychiatric treatment, "our prison system is not set up for the purpose of rendering" such care, he said.

"This case is not going to be over at the sentencing," he added. "This case is going to be interesting to follow years from now when parole eligibility comes into play."

Mr. Hribal is likely to get some treatment in prison. About a quarter of inmates currently receive psychiatric or psychological care, Dr. Robert Marsh, director of the Department of Corrections psychology office told the Post-Gazette in 2015.

Advertise with us

As the case nears its end, Mr. Peck has reflected on how it left its mark on local residents.

"Even though a case may come to a conclusion in the courts, I'm still mindful of the fact that this will not end for years for many of these victims, even people who didn't suffer a physical injury.

"They've been emotionally traumatized by this event, and I don't think we can ever forget the trauma that's been inflicted on these people.”

The plea hearing is set for 9 a.m. in the Westmoreland County Courthouse in Greensburg.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.