The city of Greensburg improperly sued a man who had sued the city claiming police brutality, according to a federal suit brought by the American Civil Liberties Union.
The ACLU filed the complaint today, claiming that a suit brought by the city against Ed Wisneski and his lawyer, Robert Owsiany, was a violation of Mr. Wisneski's constitutional right to sue the government.
Mr. Wisneski initially filed his suit in federal court in 2012 against the city of Greensburg and four police officers he said abused him during a July 4, 2010 arrest.
A federal judge dismissed the case.
But last year the city filed a countersuit, claiming that the Wisneski case was frivolous. The case was filed in common pleas court in Westmoreland County, transferred to federal court and then transferred back to the county earlier this year.
In the new suit, the ACLU said the city of Greensburg should have sought attorney's fees and costs rather than file a countersuit, which forces Mr. Owsiany and Mr. Wisneski to hire someone to defend them.
While the city said its motive for suing was to deter others from filing frivolous suits, the ACLU said the action will make others with claims of civil rights abuses "reluctant to exercise their constitutional right to file a lawsuit" because they fear retaliation.
The suit says that the First Amendment bars governments from suing people who have used them for rights violations and asks a federal judge to block Greensburg from proceeding with the case.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.