Clair Fink III, the driver in the wrong-way crash that killed a Ligonier Township police officer last week, had alcohol on his breath at the crash scene and a beer can inside the company van he was driving, according to a search warrant made available Monday.
Moreover, Mr. Fink’s co-worker, who had regularly ridden as his passenger for the previous two months, said Mr. Fink’s driving seemed to worsen about five hours after they started drinking beer together and that his driving was “scary,” the affidavit supporting the search warrant said.
The search warrant, executed Friday at Conemaugh Memorial Medical Center in Johnstown for Mr. Fink’s medical records — and specifically any data about his blood alcohol content — indicates that authorities are considering a charge of homicide by motor vehicle. It also provides the first evidence directly from investigators suggesting that Mr. Fink might have been impaired during the accident May 5 that killed Lt. Eric Eslary and injured his K-9 partner, Blek.
Pennsylvania State Police have not revealed any information about Mr. Fink’s blood alcohol content at the time of the crash. Mr. Fink, 31, who apparently continues to recover from injuries sustained in the accident, has not been charged.
But judging by comments Monday from state police, it appears that the question is not whether investigators will file some type of charges in connection with the incident, but when.
“Charges won't be filed until our investigation is complete. That will take quite a while. When we file them, I will organize a press conference,” Trooper Stephen Limani said.
Read More
The crash occurred around 1:45 a.m. while Lt. Eslary, 40, was on patrol in a marked sport utility vehicle. He was on westbound Route 30, cresting a hill near Clark Hollow Road and Idlewild Park, when he slammed head-on into a commercial van being driven against traffic on the divided highway by Mr. Fink.
The van belonged to Mr. Fink’s employer, Westmoreland Pools and Spas, which is owned by Gary Pivirotto. Mr. Fink’s co-worker, Derek Gifford, 21, was a passenger in the van.
At the crash scene, four emergency responders — a trooper, a fire chief, an assistant fire chief and a paramedic — told the investigating trooper that they smelled “a strong odor of alcohol” on Mr. Fink.
It was not the first time that authorities’ concerns were raised that Mr. Fink might have been drinking and driving.
Nine years ago Mr. Fink was charged in Westmoreland County with driving under the influence and driving with a blood alcohol content of more than 0.16 — at least twice the legal limit. Mr. Fink lost his license for 60 days; the charges were dismissed upon his successful completion of an alternative rehabilitative disposition program.
Dan Joseph, Mr. Pivirotto’s attorney, said Monday he believed that Westmoreland Pools and Spa’s insurance carrier, Harleysville Insurance, was aware of the DUI case. But, Mr. Joseph added, a DUI incident from that long ago was “irrelevant” in Mr. Pivirotto’s decision to let allow Mr. Fink to drive a company vehicle.
“He had a DUI in 2006. Nine years ago. He went ARD. The insurance company was aware of it from my understanding. And he was an approved driver on the insurance. You don’t carry a ball and chain for the rest of your life,” Mr. Joseph said. “It’s not like the scarlet letter. It’s not like somebody murdered somebody nine years ago. It’s a DUI … . It’s an ARD, and it’s expunged. You don’t even have a record after that.
”I don’t know what the circumstances of the DUI were nine years ago. No one was hurt in it.”
A spokeswoman for Nationwide, which owns Harleysville, said she could not track down employees late Monday in time to respond to questions posed by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
Mr. Fink's passenger, Mr. Gifford, told the Post-Gazette last week that he and Mr. Fink had consumed most of an 18-pack of beer — either Natural Ice or Natural Light — in the hours leading up to the crash. His account was echoed in an interview conducted by state police.
An empty 16-ounce can of Natural Ice was found in the left eastbound lane at the crash site, the search warrant said. Another can was found in plain view “in the center portion” of the van, though it is not clear whether that container was empty or open.
Mr. Gifford, 21, told state police that he and Mr. Fink worked May 4 in Uniontown until about 7 p.m. They stopped at a beer distributor and bought the beer. They started drinking around 7:20 p.m. “on their way back to the warehouse” and kept drinking until about 9 p.m., the search warrant says.
When done, the men went to the Beehive Showbar, a strip joint in Salem, where they stayed for about an hour. An employee there told the Post-Gazette that neither man had anything to drink inside the establishment or in the parking lot. The employee, who declined to give her name, said the strip club had turned over surveillance video to the state police.
The men departed the Beehive around 12:42 a.m. last Tuesday, and Mr. Fink “had his last beer,” the warrant said Mr. Gifford told police.
Mr. Gifford estimated that his co-worker drank between seven and nine 16-ounce beers and told police that “Fink's driving started to get worse after they left the Beehive Showbar.”
From there Mr. Fink drove to a Sheetz in New Alexandria.
“Fink III verbally indicated that he was intoxicated,” according to the search warrant.
State police believe that Mr. Fink ended up on Route 217 and made an improper left turn onto westbound Route 30 instead of crossing Loyalhanna Creek and making the correct turn onto the eastbound lanes of the divided highway.
Mr. Gifford told police that Mr. Fink's driving was “scary,” the affidavit said.
“He told Fink on two or three occasions that he was not in his lane,” according to the affidavit.
The crash occurred a short time later. Investigators said Lt. Eslary had no warning and no time to get out of the way before the van slammed into him.
Mr. Gifford, a regular passenger who drove to work six days a week with Mr. Fink since March, said his co-worker “was impaired based upon his driving on the morning of the crash,” the affidavit said.
Mr. Joseph said his client did not condone and was not aware of the consumption of alcohol by employees at his warehouse.
“He had no knowledge of anything like that. nor would he condone it,” Mr. Joseph said.
Mr. Joseph added that Mr. Pivirotto is “devastated” by what happened.
“This is one of the finest guys you ever want to meet. He has a great business because of his character. He’s a wonderful man who’s heartbroken over this. Obviously he did not know this guy was going to drink, drive the van, go to a strip joint, He didn’t know any of this stuff.”
Mr. Fink had been upgraded to serious from critical condition last week at Conemaugh Memorial. But following the Post-Gazette’s interview of Mr. Gifford, who was recovering at the hospital from torn ankle ligaments, Mr. Fink’s name has not appeared in the hospital’s directory information. His family could not be reached for comment.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.
FROM SATURDAY: Lt. Eric Eslary laid to rest in Ligonier Township





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.