After a Westmoreland County district judge dismissed a homicide case at a preliminary hearing in August, prosecutors refiled charges against Gregory R. Randall, who is accused of fatally bludgeoning his girlfriend with a hammer and wine bottle.
Thanks to court rules, the case wound up where it started with the same district judge.
That did not sit well with the district attorney’s office.
So on Monday the president judge of Westmoreland Common Pleas Court heard prosecution arguments about why it believed, according to a written motion, that there could be no “fair and impartial proceedings” before District Judge Michael R. Mahady.
After the hearing, Judge Richard F. McCormick Jr. ordered the case to be transferred to District Judge Helen M. Kistler’s courtroom.
Mr. Randall, 57, is charged with killing Angela M. Cavalero, 52, of Laurel Mountain. On May 9, a police officer who was asked to check on Ms. Cavalero found her body by the back door of the home she shared with Mr. Randall.
Police arrested Mr. Randall based on various physical and circumstantial evidence, including the couple’s rocky relationship, wounds to Mr. Randall’s hands that he could not explain to investigators, bandages found next to the bloody bathroom vanity and bandage wrappers discovered in Mr. Randall’s car, and a bloodstain on an interior wall of the home that contained what police believe was Mr. Randall’s palm print.
The case was first assigned to District Judge Denise S. Thiel. She recused herself, so it went to Judge Mahady.
On Aug. 13, he dismissed the charges, saying the bloody print matched to Mr. Randall from the crime scene was “speculative” because DNA tests on whose blood it was were still pending.
Prosecutors refiled the charges with an amended affidavit of probable cause, this one revealing that a jailhouse informant, Carl Short, told investigators Mr. Randall had confessed to him.
“Mr. Randall bragged about how pretty the blood spatter looked all over the wall,” the affidavit said. The attack happened after Ms. Cavalero smashed a TV dinner in Mr. Randall’s face, according to the affidavit.
The refiled charges “inadvertently” went back to Judge Thiel, said Don Heagy, special courts administrator for Westmoreland County.
From there the case traveled back to Judge Mahady, based on court rules that allow the refiling of a complaint “with the issuing authority who dismissed or permitted the withdrawal of the charges.”
Neither Westmoreland County District Attorney John Peck nor any of the judges involved could be reached for comment, and Mr. Randall’s attorney did not return calls.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.