The Chartiers Valley school board on Tuesday approved the district’s 2021-22 final budget which stands at $72,158,944.

The budget comes with a 0.5462 mill tax increase, which is about $55 for every $100,000 of assessed property value. The increase brings the total millage to 18.758 mills or about $1,876 in school taxes for every $100,000 of assessed value.

The budget did not include replacing a music teacher position at the middle school, which was met with pushback from residents who spoke during public comment at Tuesday’s virtual meeting.

Teacher Michael Holl, who taught music at Chartiers Valley Intermediate School and was also the music department head, retired at the end of the 2020-21 school year. His position is not being filled.

Advertise with us

“If that position would not be filled, I think it would have a detrimental effect on the music department,” said resident Jennifer Madge, who said her two children have benefited from the music department at the intermediate school.

She was also concerned that one teacher would be left to oversee the school’s band program, which she said would limit access for students.

According to district officials Mr. Holl was one of four teachers for three elementary grade levels — grades three, four and five. Chartiers Valley has four music teachers for its seven secondary grade levels — grades six through 12. District officials stated that other school districts have one to two music teachers for grades kindergarten through five.

“I’m urging you to reconsider the blanket idea of not replacing any retirements and to fill this position with a person to start the academic year,” Ms. Madge said.

Resident Russ Pederson added, “We urge you to discuss and rethink your position on not filling the Intermediate School music vacancy.”

Advertise with us

He said the music department is a draw for some families, including his own, to move into the district.

Chartiers Valley seventh-grader Brady Bart said not filling Mr. Holl’s position “could be detrimental to the band program.”

“It really is a great life experience. It’s very similar to playing a team sport,” Brady said about playing an instrument and being in a band.

Brady also pointed out that the district has been recognized “for how great the music program is.”

One of those recognitions came earlier this year, when, for the third consecutive year, the district was named a Best Community for Music Education by the National Association of Music Merchants Foundation. Chartiers Valley was one of 686 districts in the country to be designated with the honor.

Advertise with us

Resident Liv Tobiczyk, a Chartiers Valley band member for seven years, started an online petition to keep the intermediate music position, which she said has over 1,100 signatures.

“For me, band has always been a safe haven,” Ms. Tobiczyk said. “If this was a sports coach, would you take the same stance and not fill it right way?” she asked the board.

Superintendent Johannah Vanatta thanked the residents attending the virtual meeting and those who sent emails about the music position.

Ms. Vanatta said a key part of the district’s strategic plan is to “provide robust programs while maintaining fiscal responsibility.”

“The district has also developed a six-year curriculum cycle in which a needs assessment is an integral part of this cycle,” she said. “You may not be aware, but the music department is on a needs assess for the 21-22 school year,” she added.

Advertise with us

Ms. Vanatta said that means a thorough evaluation of the music program, kindergarten through 12th grade, will be conducted and its strengths and areas of concern will be addressed.

“The department will be able to reset if need be and reinforce its vision and direction of the music program,” Ms. Vanatta said.

The needs assessment will include surveys sent to to parents, students and staff in regards to the district’s music program.

“I ask that we trust the curriculum process and the needs assessment, as it will tell us what direction we need to move forward,” Ms. Vanatta said.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.