The future of the former Star City Cinemas property is uncertain after township officials said that Horizon Properties Group LLC plans to terminate a $5 million sales agreement to buy the site.

The township announced the termination in a Sept. 29 news release, after the company said it was terminating its agreement to buy the site from the township.

Rodney Piatt, president of Horizon Properties Group, declined to comment on the decision.

Commissioners two years ago approved the sale of the 8.5-acres located at the Interstate 79 and Route 50 interchange near Washington Pike. The property sits adjacent Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC.

Advertise with us

The property was once the site of the former Mulach Steel Corp. site and was going to require remediation because of ground contamination, but township officials said that was not the reason that the deal fell through.

“Horizon’s decision is not related to the environmental cleanup process at the site,” township Manager Ryan Eggleston said in a news release. “It turns out the site actually should require minimal cleanup.”

Horizon had eyed the property with plans for a 30,000-square-foot office building, with 10,000 to 15,000 square feet of retail space, along with a limited service hotel.

“It is the township’s understanding that Horizon’s decision is based on their private circumstances, not on anything related to the township itself,” township Commissioner Joseph Horowitz said in a statement.

The township is unsure how it will move forward.

Advertise with us

“We don’t have to start cleaning it up tomorrow,” said Mr. Eggleston. “Depending on proposed use, there may be a situation on a particular proposal that does not require remediation, or a proposal needs some but not all remediation.”

South Fayette Hotel Associates, LP was originally responsible for the demolition of the multi-screen movie complex, but township commissioners unanimously awarded a contract in October 2016 to Ritenour & Sons Construction Co. Inc. to demolish the property for about $227,500.

“We will have to see how that all shakes out. For the time being, the cost of the demolition will be absorbed by the township,” said Mr. Eggleston.

South Fayette borrowed approximately $8 million in 2009 on a five-year bond to purchase the multiple-screen movie complex for $5 million. The remainder of the bond was used to fund additional township projects. In September 2016, the township refinanced the bond for $6.5 million at a savings of 26 percent.

In 2015, South Fayette originally considered two proposals for the Star City property, including one submitted by Burns and Scalo Real Estate Services, Inc., which offered $3 million.

Advertise with us

South Fayette Hotel Associates is also slated to develop a five-story, 94-room hotel, on 2.3 acres at the site of the recently demolished Knight’s Inn, 111 Hickory Grade Road, which is also across from the old Star City property.

Amy Philips-Haller, freelance writer; suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.