A woman and her son who wanted to open a film studio in Robinson are suing their former business partners.
Cyndi Casteel and her son, David Casteel, filed the complaint in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court on Tuesday against already troubled businessmen Joseph Nocito and his son, Joseph Nocito Jr.
The lawsuit includes claims for breach of oral contract, unjust enrichment, defamation and idea misappropriation.
An attorney for the Nocitos, Brian Simmons, said he had not seen the complaint and could not comment.
Joseph Nocito Jr. pleaded guilty in March in federal court to his role in a Florida real estate fraud case and is to be sentenced Feb. 11. His father is under federal investigation by the IRS for allegedly misrepresenting more than $27 million in personal expenses as being for his various companies, allowing him to avoid paying $4.4 million in taxes.
His secretary, Ann E. Harris, pleaded guilty to conspiracy in November and is cooperating with the government in its investigation. She is scheduled to be sentenced April 19.
According to the lawsuit, filed by attorney John Adamczyk, the Casteels approached the Nocitos about the business proposal and reached an oral agreement with them on June 2, 2014, to build a 152,000-square-foot film studio on 14 acres of the former Bruce Plastics building off Steubenville Pike in Robinson.
The facility, to be called “Studio C Pittsburgh” was to have been the largest, most comprehensive film studio in Western Pennsylvania, the lawsuit said. Among its amenities, the complaint continued, would be five sound stages, two kitchens for cooking shows, abundant parking and loading dock space.
The arrangement called for the Nocitos and the Casteels to each be 50 percent owners, but the Nocitos also would have received a 12 percent return on the money they used to finance the studio, plus $25,000 per month rent, the lawsuit said. Under the agreement, Cyndi Casteel would be paid $90,000 per year, and David Casteel would earn $70,000, Mr. Adamczyk wrote.
The business plan projected earnings of $5 million annually within the first three years. But according to the complaint, Ms. Casteel learned in August 2014 from the Pennsylvania Film Office that her application for certification with the state could not be approved because she was not listed as an owner for Studio C. Instead, the application listed the Nocitos as sole owners.
Then, in January 2015, the complaint continued, the Nocitos accused the Casteels of stealing from the business, alleging more had been spent on the studio’s renovations than was accounted for. The Nocitos, the suit alleges, told the Casteels they were no longer partners but employees, and if they didn’t like it, they could leave.
Mr. Adamczyk said that under Pennsylvania law, an oral contract is “just as valid and just as enforceable” as a written contract.
The complaint also alleges that after the split, the Nocitos told others in the local film industry and community that the Casteels had stolen from them, damaging both the mother’s and son’s reputations.
Dawn Keezer, the director of the Pittsburgh Film Office, said she is not aware of the studio ever beginning operations. “We were happy to have infrastructure added to the region and had high hopes for this project,” she said. “Unfortunately, that hasn’t panned out.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.