A federal judge Friday dressed down a former Air National Guard analyst who described his fraud scheme against the military as a “bad decision” made at a stressful time in his life.

“This was a criminal act. This was not just a ‘bad decision,’ ” U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Schwab scolded Robert St. Clair after telling him about his son, a Marine captain who fought in Iraq, and his brother, who served in Vietnam and Iraq.

Both served their country honorably under considerable stress, Judge Schwab said, and never violated their sense of duty.

Still, the judge gave St. Clair, 51, a break, sentencing him to two years of probation instead of prison for his role in conspiring with a former Pittsburgh-based Air National Guard colonel, Gerard Mangis, to rip off the military.

Advertise with us

St. Clair, of Bel Air, Md., pleaded guilty last year to using his position at the Air National Guard headquarters at Joint Base Andrews in Maryland to approve Mr. Mangis, wing commander of the 171st Air Refueling Wing, for extra work days that boosted his pay and benefits even though on many days Mr. Mangis did not show up for work.

In exchange, Mr. Mangis created a no-show job for St. Clair at the 171st that provided him with military pay, retirement benefits and a security clearance.

Mr. Mangis, 60, of Shaler, has pleaded guilty and is awaiting sentencing in November.

In addressing the judge as family members and military friends looked on, St. Clair cried and said he was “blessed to be part of such a great organization” and sorry that “my passion for that organization led me to a bad decision.”

Assistant U.S. Attorney Greg Melucci said that almost everyone in the courtroom, including the judge and himself, was a public servant and had taken an oath to serve the country. St. Clair violated that oath and abused his position of trust, he said.

Advertise with us

“He chose to defraud the United States,” he said.

But, he added, the fraud also was an “aberration” in St. Clair's otherwise exemplary life. Judge Schwab agreed.

He ordered that St. Clair serve six months of his two-year probationary term on home confinement, perform 100 hours of community service helping military families and pay about $15,700 in restitution to the Air National Guard.