After state police in Beaver County charged him 20 years ago with molesting three children over the span of a decade, Lynn O. Cozart told co-workers that if he was found guilty, “he would never spend a day in jail.”

That turned out to be true — until now.

Cozart was arrested Thursday by the FBI and local police at a Wal-Mart store in Muskogee, Okla., where he had been working as a cashier under a fake name and riding to and from his apartment on a bicycle.

He was immediately jailed and will be extradited to Beaver County to serve his sentence in the molestation case, for which he faces at least 15 years.

Advertise with us

Cozart, 63, a native of New Brighton and former resident of Enon Valley who had worked as a security guard, had been wanted on a Beaver County bench warrant ever since he failed to show up for his sentencing.

In 2002, a U.S. magistrate issued a federal warrant after an FBI agent attached to the Greater Pittsburgh Fugitive Task Force said he was likely to have fled the state.

In an affidavit supporting the warrant, the FBI said co-workers had told state troopers that Cozart said he would flee if convicted.

He had long been on the most-wanted lists kept by the FBI and the U.S. Marshals Service, and in 1996 he appeared on the “America’s Most Wanted” television show. Authorities said he had ties to West Virginia, Texas and East Liverpool, Ohio, where his mother lived and where at one time he had been receiving mail at her address. His daughter told troopers that she believed his family was harboring him.

It’s not clear when he moved west, but the FBI and state troopers eventually tracked him to New Mexico and then Arkansas and finally Oklahoma.

Advertise with us

Muskogee police said he had been working at the local Wal-Mart for more than a decade, using the name David Stone.

The case broke Monday when the FBI’s facial analysis unit sent data from the Arkansas driver’s license department to the Pittsburgh FBI office. The Arkansas agency had conducted a biometric analysis using Cozart’s Pennsylvania license and a family photo and revealed that Cozart, using the fake name, had lived in Hot Springs, Ark., from 1997 to 2004, when he moved to Oklahoma.

The Arkansas agency determined Cozart’s alias, and authorities were able to track him to Muskogee, a city of 38,000.

Muskogee Officer Lincoln Anderson said another officer in his department, Sgt. Ty Pickering, recognized Cozart’s photo because he “had seen him at Wal-Mart in our city as an employee.”

Police and the FBI’s Violent Crime Task Force set up surveillance at his apartment and at the Wal-Mart and took him into custody at work Thursday without incident.

Advertise with us

State police in Beaver charged Cozart in May 1995 with multiple sex crimes involving three children from 1984 to 1994, and a jury convicted him in February 1996. A judge let him go on bond pending sentencing in April of that year, but he never showed up and disappeared.

Cozart had been wanted longer than any fugitive in Beaver County.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com