Bill Ostapchenko was at his Kennedy tire shop Tuesday afternoon when a neighbor ran over and asked him to come to the house across the street. He assumed his 81-year-old neighbor had fallen and needed help getting up.

What he found instead was gruesome. Thomas Nicholson had been restrained, assaulted and burned with chemicals, the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office said Wednesday.

“I walked in. I saw what I saw, and I got out of there,” Mr. Ostapchenko said.

He knew immediately that Mr. Nicholson was dead. He didn’t linger. On his way out, he noticed a broken roll of coins and took care not to touch anything. Police suspect Mr. Nicholson had been the victim of a robbery and were continuing their investigation Wednesday.

Advertise with us

It was a sad death, neighbors said, for a nice man who normally kept to himself, but often left his doors unlocked so visitors could just walk in.

“It’s beyond me how somebody could be so ruthless to do what they did to that old man,” Mr. Ostapchenko said.

He has been working at Best Deal Tires on Clever Road for about 40 years and said he knew Mr. Nicholson, who went by Tom, for most of that time. Mr. Nicholson bought a house on Fairhaven Road with his wife, Anna Marie, in 1975, according to county records, and had been living there alone since her death years ago.

Mr. Nicholson sometimes stopped by the tire shop that was cater-corner to his stone, ranch-style home. When he did, he spoke of cars, including his black Trans Am and his Cadillac. He rarely drove the cars, so he didn’t need new tires. Instead, he just asked for extra air.

The visits grew less frequent after Mr. Nicholson’s health declined. “He was hunched over a little bit,” Mr. Ostapchenko said, noting that Mr. Nicholson often used his foot to move his trash cans for pickup.

Advertise with us

One neighbor, who did not give his name, said he sometimes saw Mr. Nicholson back a car down the driveway to get his mail and then drive back up it. He said it was well-known in the neighborhood that Mr. Nicholson was in poor health.

Mr. Nicholson occasionally had visitors, including some who mowed his lawn or did other errands for him.

“All of them were friends and relatives,” Mr. Ostapchenko said. Many of them would lock Mr. Nicholson’s doors as they left. Moments later, Mr. Nicholson would unlock them.

“What he said was, he wanted people to come and visit him,” Mr. Ostapchenko said.

He said he saw Mr. Nicholson for the last time Saturday. Another neighbor reported seeing him Monday morning, police have said. Normally, Mr. Nicholson would have taken his trash out on Tuesday mornings. He didn’t do that this week.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know what could have happened,” Mr. Ostapchenko said.

Click the image above to explore homicides in Pittsburgh and Allegheny County this year. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)