A Beaver County judge on Thursday ordered an Aliquippa man to stand trial on involuntary manslaughter charges in the July deaths of his two toddlers, who died after a dresser fell on them.
David Beatty and his wife, Jennifer, both 28, also were held for court on two counts each of child endangerment at a combined preliminary hearing at the Beaver County Courthouse.
Mr. Beatty had seen Brooklyn, 2, and Ryeley, 3, sitting on the edge of a dresser drawer minutes before it toppled over, pinning the girls underneath, on July 4, according to police.
Brooklyn was pronounced dead at Heritage Valley Medical Center that day, and her sister died two days later at Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC.
In arguing for dismissal of the manslaughter charge Thursday, David Beatty's attorney, Kevin Kindred, said his client showed no reckless intent in the deaths and cited a forensic pathologist's autopsy that ruled both accidental.
During much of the hearing, Mr. Beatty sat bent over in his chair, at times with his head in his hand. His wife wept periodically next to him, dabbing tears with a tissue.
On direct examination, Assistant District Attorney Frank Martocci called Aliquippa police Detective Sgt. Steven Roberts and Beaver County police Det. Timmie Patrick to testify about "inconsistencies" in Mr. Beatty's timeline of the day's events.
First, Sgt. Roberts testified, Mr. Beatty said he responded within seconds after hearing a bang in the room next door -- then "it went from a minute or two to five minutes."
Det. Patrick testified that Mr. Beatty told him he was using the toilet, and it may have been up to 25 minutes before he checked on the girls after hearing the loud noise.
He said he called out to Ryeley once he heard the bang, but did not hear a response, Det. Patrick said.
Prosecution witness Todd Luckasevic -- an Allegheny County medical examiner's office forensic pathologist who performed the autopsies -- testified that the girls would have made a full recovery if someone had responded within 30 seconds.
After 90 seconds, he said "you'd have no chance" of survival.
"If [the response] was immediate, the children would be alive," he said.
Dr. Luckasevic testified that both girls died of asphyxiation due to compression of the chest and ruled the deaths accidental "because the result of their death was unforeseen."
Further, he testified that the impact of dresser did not cause their deaths, rather the "sustained weight" of the furniture.
Mr. Kindred argued how long it took his client to respond is irrelevant.
"It establishes a dangerous pattern," he told reporters after the hearing. "If you're charging parents for not responding within 30
seconds to children who have accidents that cause life-dangering issues, that exposes everyone to the danger. How do you distinguish? How is that reckless?"
Jennifer Beatty's attorney, Dale Fouse, maintained that the condition of the house -- while "a mess without question" -- does not relate to the criminal charge of child endangerment.
Police described the Irwin Street home in court as "very filthy" with clothing strewn about, feces on some furniture and "a high amount of clutter."
The couple have three other children, ages 4, 5 and 8, who are staying with relatives. Ms. Beatty and those children were not home when the incident occurred.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.