Last April, Montour School District officials started grappling with the kind of mystery most local governments would love to face. How, they asked themselves, did a district that had been struggling to control costs on a high school renovation end up with a more than healthy $28.7 million in the bank?
That discovery has sparked a year of revelations in the district that educates nearly 3,000 students in Robinson, Kennedy, Ingram, Thornburg and Pennsbury Village. Among revelations:
• A Democratic activist, John Wovchko, knew more about district finances than did board members.
• The district was paying for two overlapping sets of photocopiers, for a year, under leases set up by a politically involved firm.
• Allegheny County Treasurer John Weinstein's campaign supporters have won key service contracts.
• Political contributions by Montour School District vendors
• A board member and the superintendent have been subjects of ethics probes exploring any overlap between business interests and governmental roles.
Now a forensic audit nears completion, and a dozen candidates jockey for six seats on the nine-member board in the May 17 primary.
Those events may or may not solve the Montour mystery. But this much is already clear: In Montour, more than most places, the school's business has been an education in politics.
The balance
Before they knew they had money, Montour officials argued about whether to recycle the brick when renovating the high school. When they learned they were flush, things got rough.
Board President Ronald Smith said he only learned that the district had $28.7 million when "the Democratic chair in Robinson blurted it out in [an informal] meeting" of civic leaders.
"We were talking about, we might have to raise taxes in the school district, and he said, 'You can't raise taxes! You've got $28 million you're sitting on!'"
That Robinson Democratic Committee chair, Mr. Wovchko, 66, is a retired Sto-Rox School District teacher and administrator.
Mr. Wovchko said it is ludicrous to think the board didn't know about its bank balance, since members voted on capital spending, including a multimillion dollar stadium project in 2009. "[And if] they didn't know about it?" he asked. "Shame."
Some board members said they weren't surprised at the bank balance. They had, after all, raised taxes in 2004. Others were insulted to find that they knew less about basic district finances than did Mr. Wovchko, whose only formal role in the district is to elect Democrats as board members.
"I doubt if there was anything he didn't have say over -- whether we replace a furnace or we do this or do that, who gets hired," said Mr. Smith. "If someone wasn't doing their job and was going to get in trouble, he'd step in.
"I couldn't say that he gained anything from it," he added.
"I love Montour," said Mr. Wovchko. He said he has been involved in district matters, because he wanted "to help local people get employment. If you [as Democratic chair] can't help your own people in your community, who is going to help the residents?"
Schools are never politics free, said Carl J. DeJulio, a veteran superintendent who ran Montour in 2006 and 2007, and then served as a consultant on its construction work before he retired. What's unusual about Montour, he said, is, that the "Democratic Party in Robinson seems to have a direct influence on outcomes that occur in the school district."
Mr. Wovchko is "controlling to the point that he wants to tell you what to order when you're out at dinner," said board member Bill Ewonce, who was a friend of Mr. Wovchko's before they split last year over political differences.
News of the balance, and other disputes, led to the suspension of another of Mr. Wovchko's friends, district business manager Sam Reichl.
Mr. Reichl was accused in an August of "neglect of duty," including failure to complete audits, pursue available state funds, and ensure that vendors had contracts.
Mr. Reichl denied the accusations, but declined to comment further.
At a school board meeting last month, Superintendent Donald E. Boyer noted that the district was going after "almost $1 million in [state] reimbursement that Mr. Reichl failed to apply for."
The district signed a separation agreement with Mr. Reichl, but continues to probe his tenure. In late January, the board hired accounting firm Schneider Downs & Co. for $260,000 to conduct a forensic audit of the district's spending since 2003.
The building
In September 2008, P.J. Dick Inc. was the contractor managing the renovation of Montour High. That changed the next month, as P.J. Dick's contract ended, and Burns & Scalo Real Estate Services was hired to replace them.
One question in the Montour mystery: Did a fax addressed to Mr. Weinstein presage the change?
The renovation of Montour High got rolling years earlier, with the 2006 hiring of architect Victor Graves. In 2007, the district borrowed $48.7 million for the project, and hired P.J. Dick Inc. for $1.01 million.
Bids for the project came in higher than expected, and the board rejected them. The board fired Mr. Graves, and he sued, claiming the district stiffed him for $1.93 million. That lawsuit continues, even as the district last month settled claims of two other cancelled contractors, agreeing to pay them a total of $170,000.
On Sept. 11, 2008, Mr. Reichl, then the business manager, faxed off a copy of the district's contract with P.J. Dick. According to the fax transmission report, he addressed it to Mr. Weinstein, but sent it to the fax number of Green Tree-based Burns & Scalo. Seven months later, the district inked a construction management contract worth as much as $1.47 million with Burns & Scalo.
Presented with the fax, Mr. Weinstein said, "I've never seen any of this. ... Now, I do know [firm president] Jim Scalo."
"Someone may have asked me, was Burns & Scalo a good company," and he would have replied that it was, Mr. Weinstein said.
Mr. Scalo is also a contributor to his campaign.
Mr. Weinstein, of Kennedy, called the district's politics "a quagmire," and said he doesn't "have any relationship with [Mr. Wovchko] or involvement with Montour."
He and his father, Kennedy Treasurer Mel Weinstein, lead that municipality's Democratic Committee and help the party's candidates to win board seats, he added.
His office employs the children of school board members Gregory Clarke and Anne Mazza, but he said he doesn't tell them how to vote.
Board president Smith said the Weinsteins don't meddle in personnel decisions. They have "helped the board when we needed help. They'd give us advice on things."
Burns & Scalo proved to have very little school construction management experience.
"Basically, they came in and they did a dog and pony show and told us how they wanted to get into this aspect of construction and they had the capabilities of doing the job, and all of this stuff about what they could do," said Mr. Smith.
By November 2009, Mr. Boyer was withholding payment to Burns & Scalo due to what he called in correspondence "deficiencies" in the firm's work.
In January 2010, new architect Paul Apostolou wrote to Mr. Boyer, indicating that he was dismayed that the Burns & Scalo "never prepared a budget" beyond vague estimates.
Jim Scalo could not be reached for comment.
Payments to Burns & Scalo continued through March 2010, totaling $644,412. Then the board replaced Burns & Scalo with Thomas & Williamson Project Management.
"As it turns out, things are working out really well, and the school project looks like it's progressing really fast," said Mr. Smith. "I think we're going to have maybe the most high-tech school in the county."
The lawyers
The district's termination of Mr. Graves led to the hiring of a law firm, Goehring, Rutter & Boehm, that has deep ties to John Weinstein.
Attorney Ira Weiss, another supporter of Mr. Weinstein who was then the district's solicitor, suggested in 2008 that it hire Goehring to defend against Mr. Graves' lawsuit.
The relationship blossomed.
Through January of this year, Goehring billed $152,929 for work on the Graves case, $48,216 for its work on the high school, $6,780 for legal work related to the elementary school's roof, and $84,770 for a series of assignments the district would not detail.
In February, Mr. Weiss said he could no longer handle the job of district solicitor. The board decided to entertain competing proposals from firms interested in being its primary counsel.
"We interviewed four attorneys," said Mr. Smith. Goehring "came off the best."
John Weinstein, he added, "gave them basically an endorsement, saying they were good."
Goehring, Rutter & Boehm works closely with Jordan Tax Service and Mr. Weinstein's office on county delinquent tax collections. In 2006, when a former treasurer's office employee sued Mr. Weinstein for wrongful termination, Stacey F. Vernalis, of Goehring, led his defense. The case was dismissed.
The firm's members have been consistent contributors to Mr. Weinstein's campaign and to the Kennedy Democratic Committee.
Mr. Weinstein said he does not consciously tap district vendors for contributions. "I don't really think [the contributions have] anything to do with Montour."
Duplication
Just as Mr. Reichl's suspension began, a check arrived in Montour's offices for more than $80,000, from Connellsville-based Ford Business Machines. Officials initially wondered what it was for.
Ford Business had, for years, provided photocopiers to the district, and in 2006 it set up a new lease charging $13,988 a month. In 2009, it refinanced that lease, providing new copiers and lowering the monthly payment to $13,075 monthly.
The problem: Ford Business didn't pay off the 2006 lease. So from August 2009 through July 2010, the district paid on both leases. Instead of shaving $913 a month from its copier costs, it nearly doubled them, resulting in $325,000 in total payments for copy machines over 12 months.
Ford Business President John Garlow said his firm reimbursed Montour for part of the duplicate payment, to the tune of $80,000, even though some of the fault lies with the district. He said his firm delivered new copiers, but Montour's administration "did not want the equipment installed. ... The [information technology department] would not even let us connect them."
Since the district had two sets of copiers -- old ones installed, new ones in waiting -- it had to pay two leases, he said.
Why would the district be slow to install new copiers? District staff "said it was because of politics," Mr. Garlow said. "We were friendly with the old board, and this was a new board."
Mr. Garlow was, in 2006 and 2007, a repeat contributor to Mr. Wovchko's Robinson Township Democratic Committee.
He also did business with board member Mr. Ewonce's firm, A.J. Printing Services, paying it $32,902 for printing work from 2008 through July 2010.
"My dealings with [Mr. Garlow] were just business," said Mr. Ewonce. "I make myself available. I'm a businessman."
He said he has also brokered printing work for other district vendors, including Mr. Weiss, and Mr. Apostolou. He said he doesn't strong-arm the vendors for work, and reluctantly does low-profit business card printing for them.
Prompted by a complaint, the State Ethics Commission reviewed his work with those vendors, and found no violation of conflict of interest rules.
Mr. Ewonce abstains on board votes to pay the bills of vendors for whom he prints.
Mr. Ewonce denied lifting a finger for Ford in its dealings with the district. He said his signature on the district's 2009 copier lease was forged -- by whom, he doesn't know. He added that he feels burned by Ford's dealings with the district, no longer talks with Mr. Garlow or prints for Ford, and wants a full investigation, rather than a settlement.
"If [the district is] going to end up settling with Ford," he said, "I've lost a customer and I've lost a friend over nothing."
The stumbling block preventing a settlement, said Mr. Boyer, is the district's insistence on "assurances from Ford Business Machines regarding any relationship [the firm had] with Sam Reichl" when he was business manager. He said a relationship could be a conflict of interest.
In December, months after he left the district, Mr. Reichl was reached by phone at Ford Business's office. He said he was doing consulting work.
The new boss
A veteran of numerous school systems, and one-fifth owner of consultancy Educational Management Group LLC, Mr. Boyer, 72, worked for districts statewide before joining Montour in 2009.
Mr. Boyer became the subject of an Ethics Commission investigation after the district he headed hired his firm, EMG, as its temporary business manager. A person whose identity hasn't been revealed filed a complaint saying the arrangement was a conflict of interest.
"How can he be the superintendent on a payroll, and his own personal company, of which he is a percentage of an owner, be consulting?" Montour board member Cynthia Morrow asked.
Mr. Boyer said EMG was only retained -- at $4,300 a month from September through last week -- because questions about Mr. Reichl's status, and litigation with former assistant business manager Peggy Schweitzer, prevented the district from making a permanent hire.
He said that for $4,300 a month, EMG has studied the renovation project, the prospect of putting cameras on buses, cleaning needs at the high school, and more.
Last month the district settled with Ms. Schweitzer, who was fired by Mr. Reichl, for $110,000. She starts tomorrow as the new business manager.
Mr. Boyer said a superintendent shouldn't get involved in "Republican-Democrat types of things, and by the same token, you shouldn't be influenced by them."
He did, however, contribute $250 to John Weinstein's campaign in November.
"I was invited to his cocktail party," Mr. Boyer said, "and instead of taking a complimentary ticket, I paid for one.
"I chose to go. After all, he's a county official."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.