If the Sto-Rox Vikings are going to succeed this year, outhitting their opponents on the football field is no longer going to be enough.
They're also going to have to outhit when it comes to the books -- by a lot.
The Sto-Rox School Board on Thursday approved new standards requiring high school students to get a C or better in all their core classes to take part in sports and other extracurricular activities. That exceeds the standard of the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association, which requires student athletes to maintain a weekly passing grade -- D or better -- in courses that total four full credits.
"In my opinion, we're not going to have a football team," board member Luanne Schipani said. "You can have a kid getting an A in English and an A in history, but maybe he's in trigonometry and he's struggling. They are not going to be able to get all C's."
Ms. Schipani was outvoted 7-1, however, with other board members insisting the standard is attainable.
"I think we should set the bar high," board member Kelly Cropper Hall said. "If they can't get C's, then they shouldn't be playing."
Reached after the vote, Sto-Rox football coach Ron Butschle said he would do everything in his power to support the policy, but also noted that he wouldn't have met the new standard when he was in high school.
"I was really good in English and really, really bad in math. I had A's in all of my courses, but a D in math," he said.
"I will support whatever academic standard the school sets. I'm going to try to be proactive with working with the faculty and trying to give our players any kind of help that they might need academically to maintain that."
Principal Melanie Kerber called the policy "unconventional."
"We now have the highest standards in the district in the school with the lowest test scores in the district," she said.
She noted that she would do her best to see that it works. "The kids will be reminded daily," she said, "and I will be monitoring the classrooms."
Melissa Mertz, assistant executive director of the PIAA, said districts are free to set standards higher than the minimum, and added she had heard of districts with similar policies. It's not data the association collects.
"There was a school district that imposed that they had to be passing in five full-credit subjects. Some say they have to be passing all of their courses. Some of them require a C or better. And what one school considers their passing grade percentage may be lower or higher than another," she said.
Tim O'Malley, executive director of the Western Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic League, said he didn't know whether any other Western Pennsylvania schools required student athletes to maintain a C average in all courses.
"It's totally up to them if they want to impose more stringent standards," he said.
Dr. Kerber said the new policy grew out of concerns about the behavior of some football players last year.
"There was a noted lack of discipline, a lack of respect," she said, echoing concerns raised last year by some board members.
"There are a lot of good kids who work hard," Dr. Kerber said. "But there are also those who think they can just show up and get by. ... At some point they need to demonstrate that they want to improve, that they want to be better."
But Ms. Schipani, whose son played football, said many of the athletes succeed overall while struggling in some subjects. "Even my son had D's," she said.
Sto-Rox plays Carlynton and Cornell in football this year, and both of those high schools have academic standards that aren't as unforgiving.
Bob Susini, principal at Carlynton Junior-Senior High School, said athletes can have a failing grade in one class, but are benched for anything below a D in a second one.
"It's worked pretty well. Last year during the fall sports season we didn't have one athlete ineligible for football," he said. "As far as the varsity level goes, there were very few situations where we had students who were ineligible in a given week."
To improve athletes' grades, two years ago Carlynton established the "study zone," where athletes can work inside on school work during the hour or two between their last class and the start of practice. "It helped in terms of providing the students with more structure before practice, and it's had a positive effect on their grades as well," Mr. Susini said.
The Cornell School District requires a passing grade in all classes. That's been enough to improve athletes' scholarship, said Donna Belas, the superintendent.
"It does make the student athletes very cognizant of the fact that they are accountable for their work and they can't slack off in any way whatsoever," she said.
The grades are monitored weekly, as required by the PIAA, and a student is occasionally disappointed to have to sit out a big game due to poor classroom performance that week, she said.
"Typically it happens one time and they know you mean business. It doesn't happen again," she said.
Although she said she understood the Sto-Rox board's desire to set meaningful goals for their athletes, she worried that setting too high a standard could be the last straw that leads struggling students to drop out.
"You want them to be in school. Sometimes athletics is the hook that keeps them interested in academics," she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.