Pennsylvania State Police have arrested a Washington County man accused of killing his neighbor’s horse earlier this month.

Timothy Ray Cain, 57, of Monongahela was charged Wednesday with aggravated cruelty to animals, theft, tampering with evidence and other offenses.

According to a criminal complaint, Stacey Guth, the horse’s owner, called Carroll Township police April 9 to report the 9-year-old Gypsy Vanner named Jasper missing.

She told police she heard what she believed to be gunshots behind her house and thought that someone might have killed or injured Jasper.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cain owns the land behind Ms. Guth’s home, and the two had problems previously because of horses going onto each other’s properties, according to the complaint. One time, the complaint said, Jasper impregnated a mare owned by Mr. Cain, causing him to become angry with Ms. Guth.

Ms. Guth told police that Mr. Cain had some property in Marshall County, W.Va., which police asked authorities there to check.

A Marshall County sheriff’s deputy found a dead horse on the property that matched the description of Jasper, according to the complaint. An open-top dump-style trailer registered to Mr. Cain was also found at the location, the complaint said.

Back in Pennsylvania, a veterinarian examined Jasper and found that he had been shot in the jaw and neck, the complaint said. His jaw was broken, as were multiple vertebrae.

Mr. Cain could not be reached for comment. He faces a preliminary hearing May 3.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.