A Pittsburgh man who was run over by a drunk driver while lying intoxicated and handcuffed on a Washington County street six years ago has lost his excessive force claim against the police.

A federal court jury on Monday found in favor of two Washington police officers, Michael Cain and James Markley, in a federal civil rights suit brought in 2013 by Jerry Ray, who was 50 at the time.

Mr. Ray was found lying facedown near the intersection of Jefferson Avenue and West Chestnut Street about 2:14 a.m. Oct. 16, 2011.

The officers handcuffed him in the street because they said he refused their commands. He was lying there when James Risbin, a state prison guard, drove through the intersection after stopping at a bar and ran Mr. Ray over. Mr. Ray was badly injured and flown to a Pittsburgh hospital for treatment.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ray’s suit said the police were wrong to leave him there helpless to be run over, but the officers said they were trying to help him off the street when he was struck.

In his closing argument last week, Mr. Ray’s attorney, Gary Ogg, said the public should expect better conduct from its police.

“This is about the Fourth Amendment. This is about excessive force,” he said. “They should have moved him off the road.”

He also said the officers lied in their reports by saying they thought Mr. Ray had a gun and that they felt threatened, which is why they said they handcuffed him.

Mr. Ogg said Mr. Ray had no gun and that cuffing him was unnecessary and left him vulnerable.

Advertise with us

“There was no real threat there,” he said.

But Jack Cambest, who represented the officers, said Officer Markley had previously arrested Mr. Ray for having a gun and thought he might have one again.

He said the officers found Mr. Ray lying in the street in a dangerous neighborhood after he’d been drinking at a nearby bar. He initially got up and staggered away, they said, but he did not walk to the curb where officers directed him, instead walking in the other direction and making “furtive movements” as if reaching for a gun.

“He never stopped,” Mr. Cambest said.

The officers said Mr. Ray walked into and bounced off a traffic pole and fell down in the street. Officers handcuffed him where he lay and put their flashlights on strobe setting to warn oncoming traffic.

Advertise with us

They said Officer Markley was attempting to get Mr. Ray to his feet when Mr. Risbin drove through the intersection. Officer Markley dived out of the way.

Mr. Risbin said he heard both his front and rear wheels run over Mr. Ray. In court he apologized for the incident and said he feels terrible about the injuries he caused.

Mr. Ray suffered a head injury from the impact of the car and has lingering brain trauma.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.