A Washington County man has been charged with homicide in the fatal shooting last month of an unarmed intruder who broke into his trailer.
The decision to charge David W. Murray in the November death of Nathaniel K. Gardner came after the county’s top prosecutor determined that the defendant could not invoke the state’s “castle doctrine” legal defense.
District Attorney Eugene Vittone today said that because Mr. Murray, 53, was engaged in illegal activity in his Cecil home — namely a “large marijuana growing operation” — the defense would not apply in the death of Gardner, 52, of Washington.
The castle doctrine defense gives a homeowner the right to use deadly force to protect life, family or house against an intruder.
“People engaged in illegal drug activity cannot invoke the castle doctrine as justification for the use of deadly force,” Mr. Vittone said in a statement released today. “Criminal activity on the premises is a specific exception to a homeowner’s ability to utilize the castle doctrine to justify the use of deadly force.”
The law states that the defense cannot be invoked by someone who “is engaged in a criminal activity or is using the dwelling, residence or occupied vehicle to further a criminal activity.”
Police said Mr. Murray shot and killed Gardner Nov. 25 around 6:15 p.m. after he broke into Mr. Murray’s trailer in the 100 block of Adams Street and assaulted him. Mr. Murray told police it was the second such incident since Nov. 19.
Mr. Murray was arraigned and faces a preliminary hearing Dec. 19. In addition to homicide, he is charged with 77 drug-related offenses.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.