A 30-year-old murder case looks destined to resurface in Washington County.
A federal judge has ordered the state to retry Thomas Gorby or let him go.
Gorby, 57, of Eighty-Four, is serving life after a Washington County jury convicted him in September 1986 of robbing and killing Drayton Spahr, 39, the year before.
Gorby has been filing appeals ever since and on Wednesday U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti granted his federal petition for a new trial on the grounds that his trial lawyer, Daniel Chunko, was ineffective.
The judge said the lawyer failed to pursue a diminished capacity defense in which he could have argued that Gorby was unable to form the intent to kill Spahr, a requirement for a first-degree murder conviction, because he was drunk and mentally ill.
Instead, Mr. Chunko argued that Gorby was innocent and that someone else killed Spahr.
"Had his attorney adequately investigated the available defense," Judge Conti said, "Gorby would have made an informed decision to authorize his counsel to concede liability and pursue a diminished capacity defense in pursuant of a third degree murder conviction."
That defense would have required Gorby to admit that he killed Spahr, but third-degree murder does not carry an automatic life sentence.
Judge Conti also said that Gorby has indicated he would have authorized his lawyer to pursue the diminished capacity defense even if it put him at risk for a second-degree murder conviction, which does carry a life sentence.
The judge said that she can't predict what a jury would do but that Mr. Chunko did not investigate those options as he should have.
She gave the Washington County district attorney's office 120 days to put him on trial again or release him from prison.
Gene Vittone, the local district attorney, said he just learned of the decision Thursday and hadn't decided if he will prepare for trial or appeal the decision to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. He said his staff will review the case, talk to the victim's family and try to find witnesses, which could be difficult after so many years.
Mr. Chunko did not respond to a request for comment.
Gorby was convicted on circumstantial evidence. Trial testimony showed that he and Mr. Spahr met at a bar, the Old Trails Inn, where Spahr flashed a large roll of cash. Gorby requested a ride from Spahr and later came back to the bar with a roll of cash and wearing Spahr's distinctive chain belt. He also had blood on his pants.
In addition, Gorby's girlfriend said he confessed that he'd killed Spahr with a knife in Spahr's car after Spahr gave him the ride.
At trial, Mr. Chunko maintained that his client did not kill Spahr. But at post-conviction hearings Gorby said Mr. Chunko never brought up the possibility of arguing that Gorby was too drunk and mentally deficient to form intent to kill.
Judge Conti also said that Mr. Chunko should have considered seeking a delay of the trial so he could find some experts to testify about Gorby's mental state, especially after Gorby told him he'd killed Spahr.
"Given Chunko’s lack of investigation," the judge said, "the court concludes that Chunko’s representation of Gorby was blatantly deficient at least with respect to his failure to investigate a diminished capacity defense."
A jury convicted Gorby of first-degree murder and he was sentenced to death. The state Supreme Court overturned the death sentence on the claim of diminished capacity and he was sentenced to life.
Gorby then filed his federal appeal in 2012.
Judge Conti said that had the jury heard evidence of Gorby's "mental defects," there is "reasonable probability that the result of the trial would have been different."
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-944-6551.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.