A former Burgettstown police officer has been charged with homicide for shooting a Robinson man — the father of his daughter’s child — in what his attorney said was a matter of self-defense.

James A. Bongiorni, 68, of Burgettstown turned himself in to authorities Tuesday morning. He was arraigned and is being held in the Washington County Jail without bond.

Police said Mr. Bongiorni shot Brian Wilbert, 38, on April 27 just after 9 p.m. The brief police affidavit supporting Mr. Bongiorni’s arrest does not provide any information about a possible motive or describe the circumstances leading up to the shooting.

Mr. Bongiorni’s attorney, Robert Del Greco, does not deny that his client fired the shot that killed Wilbert. He claimed, however, that Mr. Bongiorni fired one bullet in self-defense after Wilbert threatened his daughter and brandished a knife of “considerable size.” He said his client had a properly licensed handgun.

Advertise with us

“Wilbert had brandished it in such a way that he [Mr. Bongiorni] was in fear for his life,” Mr. Del Greco said Tuesday evening. He said the shooting was not premeditated.

The incident occurred on the street outside the daughter’s house, according to Mr. Del Greco; his client lives next door.

During the hours leading up to the shooting, Wilbert “implied murderous intentions” against Mr. Bongiorni’s daughter in a series of texts, Mr. Del Greco said. Authorities were notified via 911, he added.

Mr. Del Greco called his client a “pillar of the community” who is a local businessman, and he described Wilbert as someone with a criminal record and a “notorious reputation for violence.” It was not known how long Mr. Bongiorni had been a policeman.

Although aware that an arrest was possible, Mr. Del Greco said he and his client nonetheless hoped that the district attorney’s office would decline to file charges.

Advertise with us

District Attorney Eugene Vittone could not be reached for comment.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.