A rural Washington County homeowner reportedly defending himself on Sunday from an assault by two masked men wielding ax handles shot one of the intruders dead, according to Pennsylvania State Police.
The dead man, Robert J. West, apparently was doing some sort of work on Nicholas Dziyak’s home on McGirts Road in West Pike Run Township.
“It was a business dispute,” Trooper Matthew Jardine said. He had no further information.
Mr. Dziyak, 74, was staying in a trailer on his property while the work was occurring, Trooper Jardine said.
Police said that at about 8:40 p.m. Sunday Mr. West, 42, of nearby Fredericktown and his daughter’s boyfriend, Andrew R. Graseck, 18, of Carmichaels turned off the power to Mr. Dziyak’s trailer and then knocked on his door to lure him out, according to a police affidavit and Trooper Jardine.
An affidavit of probable cause supporting charges against Mr. Graseck said “prior to their arrival the defendant and co-conspirator planned on taking the weapons to knock the victim out and steal money and anything else of value.”
When Mr. Dziyak came outside, the two men beat him with wooden ax handles, the affidavit said.
Mr. Dziyak “defended himself, firing several shots from his handgun,” according to the affidavit.
Mr. West was shot in the head and died at the scene. Mr. Graseck ran to a neighbor’s house and asked the resident to call 911.
Mr. Graseck is charged with 16 offenses, including aggravated assault and robbery, court records show.
He was arraigned and is being held on $50,000 straight bond.
Mr. Dziyak declined to comment.
Jennifer Graseck, Mr. Graseck’s mother, declined to comment because she said she had not yet been able to speak with her son.
“It’s unfortunate it happened in our township,” West Pike Run Supervisor Richard Molish said. “I don’t like to see that.”
Mr. Dziyak needed 15 staples to close two cuts on his head. His cheek also was cut, and his wrist and sternum were bruised.
Trooper Jardine said it appears that paperwork involving Mr. Dziyak’s firearm is “in proper order.”
He said it would be up to the district attorney whether to charge Mr. Dziyak in Mr. West’s death.
Washington County District Attorney Eugene Vittone could not be reached for comment.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.