The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Wednesday reduced the duties of Washington County’s president judge, citing murky reasons for doing so that the court’s spokesman was unable to explain.
A news release said Common Pleas Judge Debbie O’Dell Seneca will continue to serve as president judge and hear cases.
Her former responsibilities for caseload management, administration of personnel, assignment of judges and working with the county commissioners were assumed by Allegheny County Common Pleas Senior Judge Joseph M. James for an “indefinite” period.
He is now interim administrative judge of Washington County.
Judge O’Dell Seneca’s salary remains $175,549. Judge James will earn a daily rate of $536.
A news release cited the move as “an opportunity to strengthen the Washington County bench in light of challenges the court system has experienced in recent years, including judicial vacancies and time-consuming, complex litigation.”
But Art Heinz, spokesman for the Administrative Office Pennsylvania Courts, could provide no specifics about the issues of vacancies and complex litigation or how they related to Judge O’Dell Seneca.
“I have no information about when or whether [Judge O”Dell Seneca] requested the need for a senior judge or any one specific area of concern that may have triggered such a request,“ Mr. Heinz said.
A member of the judge's staff said she had no further comment beyond what was included in the news release.
Now in the midst of her third 10-year term, Judge O'Dell Seneca, 61, has been the subject of controversy in recent years.
Local lawyers have accused her of tampering with transcripts in a murder trial, a matter that is pending in federal appellate court.
The judge also was named in a whistleblower lawsuit brought by a former county juvenile probation employee, who alleged that she was eavesdropping on private courthouse conversations.
Mr. Heinz said the move by Supreme Court Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille was not disciplinary.
“I don’t really understand how or why one would even think that it would be punitive,” Mr. Heinz said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.