Spirited debate and controversy livened up this year's race for an empty judicial seat on the Washington County Common Pleas Court, where four candidates cross-filed for a nomination from each party.
Leading the race Tuesday night for the Democrats was Gary Gilman, 48, of North Strabane, who appeared poised to run away in a landslide victory as South Strabane lawyer Lane Turturice, 38, held a steady lead for the GOP nod.
A master and hearing officer for the Allegheny County courts, Mr. Gilman, who is married to Washington County Common Pleas Judge Katherine Emery, reported more than $100,000 in campaign spending and contributions -- more than any other candidate.
He also received more "highly recommended" votes than any other candidate among Washington County Bar Association members in a poll released earlier this month.
Mr. Turturice is best known as solicitor for several local governments. He used his campaign Facebook page last night to thank supporters and post results.
Perhaps most surprising was the news that Judge Phil Melograne probably would not be advancing to the general election in November.
Judge Melograne, 50, is the former Peters lawyer who has temporarily been filling the empty seat, left vacant last summer with the death of Judge Mark Mascara.
Also trailing Tuesday night, in both parties, was Charles E. Kurowski, 59, a Canton lawyer, making his sixth try for a judicial seat.
The local legal community expressed anger and dismay in October, when then-Gov. Ed Rendell appointed Judge Melograne, although local lawyers said they were told budget constraints would prevent such action.
The appointment was opposed by the county bar association and by state Supreme Court Chief Justice Ronald Castille, who said he had an agreement with Mr. Rendell to delay appointments due to budgetary problems.
The issue caused even more controversy when Judge Melograne announced he was seeking a full, 10-year term on the bench, along with the three other candidates.
Washington County election results can be found at http://www.co.washington.pa.us/custompages/results/primary_Election_2011/index.htm?menuDept=23.
State election results can be found at http://www.electionreturns.state.pa.us/.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.