Administrators in the Bethel Park School District this week presented the district’s kindergarten through eighth grade feasibility study, which outlined four options on how to move the district forward in the future. All of those options involve a reconfiguration that would move sixth grade from Neil Armstrong Middle School to Independence Middle School.
Last fall the district contracted with Hayes Design Group Architects for the feasibility study, which looked at the district’s facilities, infrastructure and campuses, said superintendent James Walsh at the Oct. 27 virtual public meeting.
“The one thing that we keep saying over and over to make sure we’re clear on this is we cannot do nothing,” Mr. Walsh said.
The completed feasibility study showed the district’s seven kindergarten through eighth grade buildings are all aging and major investments would be needed for things like accessibility and security improvements. Estimates to renovate all of the buildings were between $70 million and $100 million.
Common to all buildings were issues regarding compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, the need for security and safety upgrades, replacing outdated finishes, and upgrades to school sprinkler systems. Other recommended upgrades at the schools included heating, new air conditioning and ventilation systems, paving, electrical work, water line work and exterior work such as brick pointing and window replacement.
“They have to address these issues so that the buildings are not falling apart around the staff and students or that we catch ourselves by surprise when a boiler won’t light on a cold day in the winter,” Mr. Walsh said.
Hayes first listed 11 options on how to reconfigure the district, which were then narrowed down to the four recommended options.
One option is to keep all the current elementary schools and move all fourth graders to Neil Armstrong Middle School, which would then become a fourth and fifth grade intermediate elementary building. Sixth grade would move to Independence Middle School. The elementary schools would be renovated to provide equity in all buildings. The estimated cost of this option is $43.5 million.
Another option would be to close two elementary buildings and make Neil Armstrong Middle School a fourth and fifth grade building. The sixth grade would then move to Independence Middle School, and the remaining kindergarten through third grade population would be reassigned to the three remaining elementary schools. The total construction cost for this option would be $31.5 million.
A third option would be to close all existing elementary school buildings and build a new kindergarten through second grade primary center. In this option, Neil Armstrong Middle School would be expanded and renovated into a third through fifth grade elementary center, and sixth grade would move to Independence Middle School. The cost would be between $47 million and $48 million, depending on where the new center is built.
One scenario would have the new primary center being constructed on existing fields at Neil Armstrong, and the other has it being constructed on existing property at Benjamin Franklin Elementary.
The opportunity for full-time kindergarten would exist in this option as well as in the final one.
The final option is to close all existing elementary schools in the district and build a kindergarten through third grade elementary center. Neil Armstrong Middle School would become a fourth and fifth grade school, and sixth grade would move to Independence Middle. The cost would be $43 million for this option.
One option in this scenario is to construct the new kindergarten through third elementary center on the existing fields at Neil Armstrong, and another would be to construct it on existing property at Franklin Elementary.
“All four of the remaining options that the board has to consider include moving the sixth grade to IMS (Independence Middle School) to put it back to its original design and to capitalize on its middle school concept,” Mr. Walsh said.
Mr. Walsh said the timeline for any sort of reconfiguration or “ribbon cutting” is between 30 and 36 months away.
Once the board commits to an option, it would be about two months until the board would vote on an architect and to advance the work. It would then be roughly another eight months for the architect to develop plans and another two months after that for bids to be awarded and work to begin. After a contract is awarded, Mr. Walsh estimated it would take between 18 and 20 months for renovations or between 20 and 24 months for new construction.
The feasibility study can be found on the district’s website, www.bpsd.org under the “facilities planning” tab.
Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.