With COVID-19 numbers spiking in Allegheny County, the Mt. Lebanon School Board on Monday reaffirmed that the district will remain in its hybrid model for the time being.

Additionally, school directors approved a resolution giving Superintendent Timothy Steinhauer the authority to close any school building and opt for remote learning for that building in the event of a COVID-19 outbreak.

Mt. Lebanon has been in the hybrid learning phase since Oct. 5. In hybrid, students attend class in person two days a week and learn remotely from home the other three.

Prior to the vote to remain in the hybrid model, Mr. Steinhauer explained to the board that the county is now in the “substantial” range of virus transmission when it comes to incidence rates of COVID-19, at 138.7 cases per 100,000 residents.

Advertise with us

The state Department of Education stated that an incidence rate of anything above 100 is considered to be substantial.

Mr. Steinhauer said there has been “a really precipitous rise” in the incidence rate. He said it went from 65.9 from Oct. 30 to Nov. 5 up to that 138.7 number the week of Nov. 6 through Nov. 12. He said the county has been at the “substantial” level of community transmission since Nov. 13.

Additionally, the positivity rate in the county has also gone up and sits at 7.7% as of Tuesday.

The Department of Education recommends that schools go fully remote if the positivity rate is above 10% or the incidence rate is above 100.

Mr. Steinhauer did advocate to the board, based on Department of Education guidelines, to wait an additional week to see if the numbers remain at the substantial level. He recommended that if the numbers were still in the substantial range when they are released on Friday that the district then go fully remote until Dec. 4.

Advertise with us

However, he added, “It is really up to the board to make the decision.”

Board member Elaine Cappucci said while the county COVID-19 numbers are “alarming,” the school district is not seeing transmission within its buildings.

“We haven’t currently seen the schools as a vector,” said board President Sarah Olbrich. “We know that the kids do better in our buildings, but we have to keep our staff safe as well.” She added that taking a break and going remote through the Thanksgiving holiday might be prudent.

But the board came to a consensus to look at more localized data such as by ZIP code rather than countywide data in determining whether to remain in the hybrid learning model. Mr. Steinhauer added that the recommendations from the Department of Education are just that and that there is no penalty for not following them.

Board members Aviva Diamond and Valerie Fleischer wanted to table the decision until the county numbers come in Friday afternoon.

Advertise with us

Ms. Diamond said she agrees the schools have not been found to be a primary source of the coronavirus, “but there is this very rapid increase in community spread.”

“There comes almost a tipping point where it becomes more likely that we will have significant viral spread circulating within our schools,” Ms. Diamond said. “We don’t know for sure, and we don’t know what the tipping point is, but I speculate that this is likely to happen.”

Ms. Diamond added that further efforts at the state and local level also need to be implemented “in order for us to successfully be able to return to in-person hybrid instruction.”

During public comment, resident Suzanne Sieber said the students want to be in classes in the hybrid model and not remote. She encouraged the board and district to handle things the way they have been.

“If you see an increase in a building, address it there,” she said. “You should only focus on our statistics that you see in the schools and not really look at the Allegheny County statistics. I encourage you to open up the schools as much as possible.”

Advertise with us

Resident Nadia Wright said she thought the district should have fully remote instruction because that is what the district’s health and safety plan states in the case of substantial transmission.

Resident Jen Lingler said, “If we went only by whether we thought COVID would be transmitted by our schools, we would be foolishly shortsighted.”

“Making our schools safer requires making our community safer. We are intertwined, and at times like this we should behave as such,” Ms. Lingler said.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.