A staid federal courtroom echoed Monday with sobs as the daily toll of addiction played out once again in the halls of justice.
This time it was a tale of two addicts, one dead of an overdose and another heading to jail and a halfway house for giving him the drugs that killed him.
After admitting that she struggled with how to come up with an appropriate sentence, U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti sentenced Jacob Palaski, 28, of South Park, to probation and ordered him to report to the Erie County Jail on weekends for a year.
The rest of the time she said he'll continue treatment at Gaudenzia, an inpatient drug treatment program in Erie where he's been staying for the last five months to try to get sober and make something of himself.
Palaski admitted to supplying the fentanyl that killed his friend, Jesse Iwanonkiw of McMurray. Mr. Iwanonkiw texted Palaski on July 9, 2016, asking for heroin.
Palaski drove to his house and gave him 10 stamp bags that turned out to be pure fentanyl. Mr. Iwanonkiw overdosed and died the next day. He was 29.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Troy Rivetti and Palaski's lawyer, Martin Dietz, both agreed that the case was a tragedy but differed on how Palaski should be punished for what he did.
Mr. Rivetti wanted prison of up to a year. He said his office could have charged Palaski with the crime of delivering narcotics that kill or injure, which would have carried a 20-year penalty, but chose to charge him only with fentanyl distribution largely because of his addiction problems.
But he still asked the judge to "send a message that the consequences are severe" for deadly drug dealing.
Mr. Dietz said probation was appropriate because his client, unlike most drug dealers in the federal system, was not flooding the region with narcotics for profit. He said Palaski didn't mean to kill his friend and that his treatment at Gaudenzia is helping him reclaim his life from addiction.
"Let's not lose sight that some of these people can be saved," he said.
Palaski apologized to Mr. Iwanonkiw's mother and sisters as they wept.
"I wish I could take that day back," he said.
Mr. Iwanonkiw's family said they're glad that Palaski's treatment is helping him but made it clear they thought he should go to jail.
"He got help, and now it's time to pay for his actions," said his sister, Stephanie. "My brother didn't deserve this."
Another sister, Amanda, spoke directly to Palaski.
"You are my worst enemy," she said, "but all I can do is pray for you."
Palaski was indicted last year, one of many drug dealers charged federally with supplying deadly drugs as part of the Justice Department's crackdown on opioid trafficking.
He told the judge that when his sentence is done he hopes to become a drug counselor. He said his life as an addict will give him a rapport with young people that someone with a degree but no direct experience can never provide.
In addition to the jail term, the judge ordered him to pay $16,965 for the cost of Mr. Iwanonkiw's funeral.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.