A veteran West Mifflin Area teacher accused of having sex with a female student several times in his high school classroom was arraigned Tuesday afternoon and ordered to avoid contact with his alleged victim.
West Mifflin police on Tuesday charged James Horgan, 45, of Upper St. Clair, with a felony count of institutional sexual assault.
The student, who was not identified in court records, told investigators that she had sex with Mr. Horgan after school in the back of his classroom at West Mifflin Area High School. She said they had sex about four times in the past month and the most recent encounter happened March 28, according to the criminal complaint filed by West Mifflin police.
Mr. Horgan and his two sisters, who accompanied him to the arraignment before West Mifflin District Judge Richard D. Olasz Jr., declined to speak with reporters. His attorney, Patrick Thomassey, said Mr. Horgan denies the allegations.
"Right now he's entered a plea of not guilty and denied the charges, and we will go from here," Mr. Thomassey said.
Mr. Horgan sat silently in the courtroom as he waited for his arraignment, at times resting his head in his hands.
District Judge Olasz released Mr. Horgan on non-monetary bond with three conditions: report to pretrial services, be fingerprinted and avoid all contact with anyone involved in the case.
Mr. Horgan, who teaches Advanced Placement psychology class, has worked at West Mifflin Area High School for 22 years.
Mr. Thomassey said there have been no prior complaints of misconduct against Mr. Horgan, who is married and has three children. State records show Mr. Horgan has never been disciplined by the Pennsylvania Department of Education.
"He has been a model teacher, if there is such a thing anymore," Mr. Thomassey said.
He also cast doubt on Mr. Horgan’s alleged confession when asked about it Tuesday.
“Well, that’s to be litigated down the road, whether he admitted to it or not,” he said.
Police became aware of the allegation Friday, the same day Mr. Horgan was placed on paid leave from the school.
Detectives interviewed Mr. Horgan at his home on Saturday, and Mr. Horgan admitted to having sex with the student, according to the complaint.
The West Mifflin Area School District was made aware late last week of the allegations involving a teacher and student, district solicitor Gary Matta said Monday.
Mr. Matta declined to give more details about alleged misconduct or the teacher, saying only that the district and the West Mifflin Police Department were investigating.
Attorney Phil DiLucente, who is representing the student's family, said they were "devastated."
"This has been extremely disturbing and upsetting to the victim's family," he said. "While the family respects the legal process, it was devastated to learn the acts complained of in the criminal complaint occurred while on school property and that their child was a victim."
The district has been grappling in recent months with high-profile personnel problems. In September, it put an assistant coach on leave over allegations of inappropriate behavior with a student. And its superintendent, Daniel Castagna, faces a pending DUI case in Beaver County.
Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.