On May 17, 2016, Daevon Plowden sent his girlfriend a series of text messages, telling her he had it with threats being made by her ex-boyfriend.

"He said he was tired of Daniel's threats. He said he was going to kill him the next time he saw him because of the threats he kept sending to him," Lashawna Holmes testified Tuesday.

Eight days later, police said, Mr. Plowden opened fire on Daniel Jones and his friend, Tamar Taylor, on a residential street in Brentwood.

Mr. Jones was struck in the buttocks and survived. Mr. Taylor, 26, of Munhall, was struck four times in his left shoulder and back. He died at the scene.

Advertise with us

Mr. Plowden, 30, is on trial this week before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Beth A. Lazzara on charges of homicide, aggravated assault, carrying a firearm without a license and reckless endangerment.

During opening statements Tuesday afternoon, Assistant District Attorney Chelsie Pratt told the jury that Mr. Plowden’s actions were "premeditated and deliberated" and that he was responsible for first-degree murder.

On the evening of May 25, Ms. Pratt said, Mr. Jones caught a ride with Mr. Taylor to Ms. Holmes' residence on Bellanca Avenue to drop off a sleeping bag for his daughter.

But Ms. Holmes, who had dated Mr. Jones for nine years, had asked him not to come, knowing that he and Mr. Plowden did not get along.

Ms. Pratt told the jury that Mr. Plowden, who previously had been wearing a white T-shirt and gray shorts that night, changed into all black and sneaked out onto the street to confront Mr. Jones.

Advertise with us

"This case is not a whodunit," Ms. Pratt said. "There's no mystery."

Ms. Holmes testified that when Mr. Plowden went outside, he asked Mr. Jones why he was there. She said she went inside to call 911, fearing that the dispute between the two men would escalate. As she was going for her phone to call, she heard gunfire.

Mr. Plowden fired 13 shots, police said, and officers found an empty magazine in the street. Later, when they recovered Mr. Plowden's handgun, Ms. Pratt said, they found it had another loaded magazine in it.

But defense attorney Ryan James told the jury that Mr. Plowden had been threatened by Mr. Jones with a handgun at least twice in the past and that night, he was defending himself.

On cross-examination, Ms. Holmes admitted that she and Mr. Jones had a tumultuous relationship that had been abusive.

Advertise with us

She also testified that she saw Mr. Jones threaten Mr. Plowden with a handgun twice — once in October 2015 in a parking lot at the Waterfront in West Homestead, and again at some point after at her home.

Ms. Holmes said she did not see Mr. Jones with a gun on the night of the shooting. She was surprised when investigators told her that Mr. Jones was not armed.

"'He always has a gun,'" she said.

Mr. Plowden’s attorney said in his opening statement that his client thought he saw Mr. Jones pull a gun.

"He didn't give him a chance to shoot," Mr. James said.

Advertise with us

The question for the jurors, the defense attorney continued, is whether his client had malicious criminal intent.

The trial will continue Wednesday afternoon.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.