A proposed townhouse community that would be developed on the former Sisters of St. Francis property in Whitehall has raised concerns among some residents in neighboring Castle Shannon who live near the site at the intersection of Grove and McRoberts roads.

Justin Kaylor from Penn Cove Group Capital of Mt. Lebanon on Nov. 2 presented a conceptual layout of the proposal at a meeting of the Whitehall Planning Commission. The preliminary plans call for 74 two-story town home units. Mr. Kaylor said the homes would sell in the mid-$200,000 range.

The town homes are the second development to be proposed for the 33 acre site. Earlier this year, Whitehall Borough Council approved plans for a three-story retirement community for residents 55 and over that would be located on about 9 acres of the wooded and hilly property.

The three-story retirement community is to be located at the northern part of the site with construction to begin later this fall. Resort Lifestyle Communities of Lincoln, Neb., is developing the project.

Advertise with us

At the Nov. 2 meeting, Mr. Kaylor focused on the conceptual design of the townhouse development, which would be built opposite the retirement community, but said specifics could change by the time it is formally presented to planning commission.

In the conceptual plans, the former St. Francis Academy building, which currently houses the Franciscan Child Day Care Center, would be razed and a new structure built that would be dedicated solely to the daycare center. However, he said, that could ultimately change.

Several Castle Shannon residents in attendance at the meeting expressed concern about the project.

Sherri Suppa of Castle Shannon lives close to the site and said she and her neighbors started a petition, collecting more than 100 signatures opposing the project. Ms. Suppa said they were concerned about what she called “clear-cutting of a large wooded area” and noise and dirt from the construction site.

Debbie Gallo of Castle Shannon said she was concerned about the “lack of information between the three boroughs,” of Castle Shannon, Bethel Park and Whitehall.

Advertise with us

She said she is worried about increased traffic, particularly at the intersection of McRoberts and Grove Road.

“That’s one of the worst intersections,” Ms. Gallo said.

Castle Shannon resident Dan Waz asked about entrances and exits to the proposed development.

“I have a piece of property right on that corner. Your grand entrance is going to be coming right through my property,” he said. He also is concerned about increased traffic.

Mr. Kaylor said that they will be submitting a traffic study for the site, which will be part of the developer’s formal plans when an application is formally submitted to planning commission.

Advertise with us

Travis Crocker, the lone Whitehall resident to speak at the meeting, said that he lives near a town home development and that he has seen a “dramatic increase” to his property since it was built.

“There are positives here to look at if we can come together and work together,” Mr. Crocker said.

“I’m so happy to see South Hills Square there,” said Castle Shannon resident Sharon Mulac, who said after years of having “quiet sisters” there it will be nice to have another quiet group on the property.

“These people aren’t going to be throwing wild parties,” she said.

The site for the proposed townhouse development is currently zoned R-7, under which churches, senior living communities, parks and personal care facilities are permitted uses.

Advertise with us

“Currently there are no regulations to deal with this type of development,” in the R-7 district, said Scott Dellett, Whitehall’s director of planning, zoning and code enforcement. “They are being drafted,” he said.

He said that part of the revisions to the zoning ordinance will include “aspects of open space and requirements of a traffic study.”

Mr. Dellett said there will be a public hearing before those ordinance changes are officially made.

Planning Commission member Elaine Kirsch said of the retirement community, “This facility is similar to what’s on McNeilly Road,” referring to The Devonshire of Mt. Lebanon.

“You can see the impact of traffic. It’s practically nil,” Ms. Kirsch said.

Advertise with us

Planning Commission member Carol Tasillo stressed that the plans being presented were not final.

“This is conceptual. This has nothing to do with the details,” she said. “When final plans are presented, we will get all that information.”

No specific timeline was given for the town home project, as both the planning commission and council have to approve a revised ordinance before that can happen.

“When we formally present to this body (planning commission), we are still several months away from getting it to council,” Mr. Kaylor said.

Penn Cove Group Capital purchased the Sisters of St. Francis property in 2015 for $1.95 million.

Advertise with us

According to the county assessment website, South Hills Square Retirement Community is the owner of the entire 33 acre site having closed on it in late August at a total cost of $3.85 million.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.