A dispute over a proposal to house men recovering from addiction in a former Clairton church rectory has landed in federal court.

Joyce Douglass, a retired parole agent, hopes to establish Cornerstone Residence Inc. for men recovering from addiction, in the rectory of the now-closed St. Paulinus Church in Clairton.

“We’re not bringing in criminals. We’re bringing in people who are asking for help,” Ms. Douglass said.

Her proposal, which was initially for the formerly incarcerated but has since been modified, caused an outcry last year by some local residents and elected officials who said they didn’t want the facility in the rectory, at 622 Delaware Ave., in their neighborhood.

Advertise with us

In an interview, Ms. Douglass said she aims to assist those in recovery with finding employment or pursing education.

A federal lawsuit brought by Cornerstone in May as a Fair Housing complaint alleged that the city and its zoning officer, George Glagola, are applying zoning ordinances in a way that is discriminatory. The lawsuit says the city and Mr. Glagola “have interpreted and applied the City’s Zoning Ordinance in a manner which both facially discriminates against adult disabled individuals and has a disparate effect adverse to these individuals,” and should issue an occupancy permit.

The lawsuit states that the Roman Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh executed and delivered an agreement of sale for the property in March, with a nine-month zoning approval contingency.

Since then, Clairton city officials have failed to issue an occupancy permit, however.

A court filing by the city says the zoning process is not complete, and alleges that Cornerstone is trying to “shortcut” the process “because its Application for an Occupancy Permit was not immediately approved.”

Advertise with us

Clairton Mayor Rich Lattanzi could not be reached, but had previously expressed vigorous opposition to Ms. Douglass’ proposal. Deputy Mayor Lee Lasich declined to comment, citing the litigation.

Not all the city’s officials are against the idea. Councilman Richard Ford said he’s personally supportive, though he doesn’t represent the ward where the church is located.

“I think it is a good thing. Everybody knows people who have had problems,” Mr. Ford said.

Several Delaware Avenue neighbors said they were unhappy and concerned about the proposal.

“I’ve got no problem with people trying to get better, but that’s not the place,” resident Philip Boyette said.

Advertise with us

A number of other neighbors echoed his sentiments, saying they did not object to the idea of people recovering from addiction, but they had concerns that it would be harmful to their quiet residential neighborhood or the children who live there.

“If you drive through Clairton, every other building is empty,” said Georgina Rondinelli, who lives nearby, asking why the facility could not be placed elsewhere.

Another neighbor, John Hodish, said he did not necessarily object to such a facility but said he wished more was being done to address neighborhood questions and concerns.

“I think the need for drug and alcohol rehabilitation is in demand,” he said.

St. Paulinus Parish was established in 1923, although the old stone church building was not built until the 1930s, according to a history from the diocese.

Advertise with us

“[F]unds were lacking to have the church designed and built by professionals, so the parishioners built it themselves. Stone for the church came from a local quarry, the roofing came from a sheriff’s sale and lumber from old buildings was used throughout the church,” according to the history from the diocese.

The final Mass of the church was celebrated in 2007.

The Rev. Chuck Baptiste said the sale was approved by the St. Clare of Assisi Parish’s pastoral and finance councils. The parish was formed with the merging of St. Clare, St. Joseph and St. Paulinus parishes.

“Those who would be users of this property will be people like us, needing a second chance,” Father Baptiste wrote in a recent church bulletin, invoking Clairton’s nickname, “the City of Prayer.”

“I think it is a good cause, I think it is an authentic cause, and I think it is in accordance with Scripture,” he said in an interview.

Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.