Planning board members in Mt. Lebanon got an earful Tuesday from a standing-room-only crowd of residents concerned about a proposed continuing care home for seniors at the intersection of Connor Road and Terrace Drive.

After hearing more than two hours of remarks — almost entirely from those opposing the development — the board was split in a 2-2 vote on whether a zoning district should be expanded to make way for the development, being proposed by Missouri-based NorthPoint Development.

“I can understand both perspectives,” said board member Matthew Simonds, who voted in favor of expanding the zoning district. The planning board makes recommendations to the municipal commissioners, who make the final decision.

Also voting to support the request was Dennis Pittman, while Suzanne Sieber and James Cannon dissented. Member Rick Sabeh was absent.

Advertise with us

At issue is whether a current continuing care overlay district should be expanded to include the 4.5-acre property owned by NorthPoint, which now lies in a residentially-zoned district.

Continuing care homes aren’t a permitted use in residential districts, so the only way the project can go forward would be through an expansion of the continuing care district located next door -- at the Pines of Mt. Lebanon.

NorthPoint wants to build its 100-bed development, called Stonecrest Senior Living, next to the Pines, which would be a competitor. There are nine other such care homes in the municipality.

“We’re asking to extend the continuing care district by one parcel,” said Alice Mitinger, a lawyer for the developer, which hasn’t submitted any formal plans yet. The overlay district is among the first of many approvals needed before the project can move forward.

“We believe the decision to extend the continuing care district is a logical one and a good one for the community,” said Dan Thies, a partner at Stonecrest, who was jeered by the capacity crowd.

Advertise with us

Mr. Thies suggested that the care home would be a more palatable use for the property, which instead could be developed into about 13 homes under the current zoning designation.

“The traffic generated by our community would be similar to what is generated by 13 lots,” he said. “It would not have an adverse impact on the community.”

But many residents disagreed and some said they were offended by the suggestion that traffic generated by a dozen homes would be comparable to a 100-bed facility with employees, deliveries and visitors.

“That’s a fairy tale,” said resident Dan Caste. “Not every parcel of land is meant to be developed.”

“I have significant concern for my children walking in this neighborhood,” said neighbor Denise Burton. “We bought our property with the expectation that this would be developed eventually as a residential community.”

Advertise with us

“The municipality has received more than 50 letters from concerned citizens about this request,” Ms. Sieber said, including concerns about the pedestrian safety, traffic and loss of green space. Residents also mounted a petition drive.

“There are many people that are very concerned about this development,” said resident Sarah Everhart, who walked door to door collecting 295 signatures of those opposed to it. “I heard a lot of valid concerns among neighbors. We have so many kids in our neighborhood. That’s a bigger traffic impact than 13 homes.”

Lawyer Robert Max Junker told the board he was representing homeowners in the Hoodridge Plan Association, and asked the board not to approve the request.

“If it was a compatible use, it would be a conditional use” in the residential zoning district, he said. “It’s an institutional residential development.”

And although the development team cited a need for at least 31 continuing care beds in the area, inquiries to local care homes indicated they aren’t full to capacity, resident Katie Feldbauer said.

Advertise with us

“All of them have open beds,” she said.

Resident Bill Lewis was the lone supporter of the project among those who spoke Tuesday.

“This property has been vacant for many, many decades,” said Mr. Lewis, who said previous owners planned homes, a strip mall and even youth soccer fields on the property with no success. Topography on the land is challenging, with steep slopes and a wetland. “This is probably the best proposal that has come forward.”

The next step in the process will be consideration by commissioners, who will review the request at two meetings and hold a public hearing before voting on it. That is expected to begin next month.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1159 or on Twitter @janicecrompton.