A federal judge today rejected an attempt by Iceoplex owner Steven Lynch to avoid federal prison, saying the Squirrel Hill attorney is merely trying to postpone having to report to the lockup as he has ordered.
U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab also said not sending Lynch, a tax attorney, to prison would send a message that "tax-evading professionals" like him are subject to a different form of justice than everyone else.
"Simply put, the requested relief...would contravene justice," the judge said.
Judge Schwab earlier this month sentenced Lynch, 61, to 48 months behind bars and ordered him to pay $793,145 in restitution and a $75,000 fine.
But Lynch and his lawyers have since asked the judge to reconsider and impose some kind of alternative sentence, such as allowing him to serve his term through the Aleph Institute, a Jewish humanitarian organization.
Lynch, who owns the Iceoplex and other businesses at Southpointe in Cecil, has until mid-March to report to prison.
He was convicted in September on numerous counts of willful failure to pay payroll taxes from 2012 on. The IRS said he failed to withhold some $1.5 million in payroll taxes by creating a dummy corporation to shield money from the government.
His defense team said he never meant to rip off the IRS and argued that he helped people by putting the money back into his companies, saving jobs, as opposed to enriching himself.
Judge Schwab rejected that defense again today, saying he still benefited from cheating on taxes and does not deserve a sentence reduction or modification.
"Lynch argued throughout the case – including during the sentencing phase – that he 'did not take money from the business,'" the judge said, "but he did use these funds to improve his investments in these businesses."
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.