An East Pittsburgh man has sued Elizabeth Borough and two police officers in federal court, claiming that one used excessive force against him while he was under arrest and shackled at the police station and the other didn’t protect him during the incident.
Joshua Brooks, 21, says in the complaint filed Wednesday that Officer Garrett Kimmell violated his civil rights during the incident April 17, 2015, after he was arrested for suspected heroin possession.
The suit, filed in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh by attorney Todd Hollis, says Officer Kimmell hit Mr. Brooks repeatedly with his forearms, elbows and knees while Mr. Brooks was being held at the police station.
“Brooks had already been arrested, and was clearly already in police custody and control at the Elizabeth Borough Jail, with his legs shackled to a bench,” the suit says. The suit calls Officer Kimmell’s actions “wanton, malicious and oppressive.”
Elizabeth Borough officials did not respond to messages Thursday.
Attorney Anthony DeLuca, who represents Officer Kimmell, said his client was reacting to “an aggressive defendant.” He said he believes video footage shows that Officer Kimmell “stops his use of force when the defendant stops resisting.”
“Officer Kimmell, a decorated police officer who has served and protected various communities for many years, acted with an appropriate level of force as confirmed by a 'use of force' expert,” Mr. DeLuca said. “In all respects, Officer Kimmell's conduct was proper.”
Elizabeth Borough police wrote in arrest paperwork that Mr. Brooks tried to grab Officer Kimmell’s Taser, didn’t comply with a request to sit down and began to “actively resist arrest” after Officer Kimmell “attempted a pressure point to the jugular notch.” Officer Kimmell eventually used a Taser on Mr. Brooks, according to criminal court records.
The altercations unfolded before a camera at the station that captured video but apparently not sound. A video clip, which is a little less than three minutes long, shows Mr. Brooks and an officer standing face to face in the station. Suddenly, the officer reaches toward Mr. Brooks’ neck and then punches him. The two continue to struggle for some time, and at one point Mr. Brooks picks up the officer and ends up on top of him.
Eventually, another officer, identified in the suit as Dan Verno, comes into the room and pulls Mr. Brooks off his colleague, who uses a Taster on Mr. Brooks.
At various points in the video, it’s possible to see that Mr. Brooks is shackled to the bench.
Police charged Mr. Brooks with more than two dozen criminal counts ranging from aggravated assault and disarming a law enforcement officer to drug violations and false imprisonment. All of Mr. Brooks’ charges — except one drug violation — were withdrawn. Mr. Brooks last month received six months of probation without verdict for the drug charge.
The Allegheny County District Attorney’s office reviewed video from the station in September and “after consulting with a use of force expert, determined that the actions of the arresting officer were not inappropriate given the circumstances,” according to spokesman Mike Manko.
“Our office also determined in preparation for trial, which took place last month, that we could not sustain our burden of proof on the charges of assault that had been filed against Brooks, in part because the arresting officer did not sustain any serious bodily injury,” Mr. Manko added. “For that reason, all charges other than the drug possession charge were withdrawn.”
The lawsuit alleges assault and battery and excessive use of force against Officer Kimmell. It accuses Officer Verno of failing to intervene. The borough is also accused of failing to properly train and supervise the officers.
Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com. Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.
EDITOR’S NOTE: THE CONTENT OF THIS VIDEO MAY BE DISTURBING FOR SOME VIEWERS:
Police video: Joshua Brooks and Officer Garrett Kimmell




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.