The man charged with stabbing five people at a Munhall mental health facility a week ago previously underwent psychiatric treatment and was jailed several times in connection with a series of threats and violent encounters against others, including his grandparents and a former girlfriend.

Dustin Johnson, 38, of Carnegie now faces 12 counts of aggravated assault and criminal attempt-risking catastrophe, following the knife attack at Turtle Creek Valley Mental Health on West Street.

Dustin Johnson

“I 100 percent believe that Dustin knew exactly what he was doing when he walked into that place,” said Traci Werner, his girlfriend from 2005 through 2012, who since then has had sporadic contact with him. “He wanted to die being famous.”

Advertise with us

Police shot him, as he turned on them with what turned out to be a BB gun, but he survived and remains hospitalized, awaiting arraignment. The victims all survived.

Mr. Johnson was 18 years old when his grandparents — then in their 70s — accused him in a petition for a protective order of pushing, punching and threatening them, tearing up ceilings and floors, smashing furniture, breaking phones and punching through windows in their Carnegie home. They wrote that police had been called to the house six times to deal with his rampages.

For a year and a half, according to court documents, grandparents Leonard and Victoria Iacona periodically allowed him back into their lives. “The boy has no place to go,” Mr. Iacona wrote in a motion to modify the civil order. “I want to give him another chance.”

It backfired. A few months later, the grandfather wrote that he “threatened to burn house down while we sleep, always hitting us, picking us up, choking us, spits on us.”

Carnegie Detective Dennis Lawrence, who knew Mr. Johnson and his grandparents, said the young man’s troubles were limited to domestic quarrels, threats and bar fights.

Advertise with us

“He was like a loner,” said the detective. “I think the community looked at him in a different way, because he had tattoos all over him,” and often dressed in styles mimicking popular professional wrestlers.

From 1997 through 2013, he was jailed nine times, usually just for a few days, and never for more than five weeks, according to Allegheny County records.

In 2006, Mr. Johnson filed for a protective order against his father, Robert Charles Johnson. The son claimed that the father had threatened to shoot him, had guns and was using drugs and alcohol.

The father died in 2007. Ms. Werner and the detective said he apparently overdosed on drugs.

Ms. Werner was 21 and Mr. Johnson 26 when they became a couple. He told her that he had a great job in graphic design, she said, but after she quit her job, he admitted he was living on Social Security he got for a mental health diagnosis.

Advertise with us

“He was a wrestler” in an amateur league, said Ms. Werner, in an interview this week. “His alter ego was Johnny Psycho.” The tattoo covering his neck depicted the devil, with the horns winding around to the corners of his mouth, she said.

She added that he had an unexplained fascination with the number 11 — and the stabbings were on Nov. 11. But he had other, more disturbing obsessions.

“He is very, very intrigued with serial killers, always on the serial killer’s side,” she said. “John Wayne Gacy movies, like every serial killer, Ted Bundy, he had all of the movies on them.”

She recalled his favorite movie quote: “I am the devil and I am here to do the devil’s work,” which a character utters just before bludgeoning another man to death in the 2005 film “The Devil’s Rejects.”

Ms. Werner said Mr. Johnson was diagnosed with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, and had a community treatment team through Pittsburgh Mercy.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Mercy gets county funding to run four such teams, each of which consists of a physician, a registered nurse, a therapist, a care manager, a peer and other professionals. Each team works with about 100 people with severe mental illnesses. Neither the county nor Pittsburgh Mercy would say whether Mr. Johnson received such services, citing confidentiality rules.

Sometimes homeless, Mr. Johnson sought refuge at a variety of hospitals, preferring St. Clair Hospital in Mt. Lebanon, Ms. Werner said. He was treated at St. Clair in 2006, according to court records from a case in which he pleaded guilty to making terroristic threats against another woman.

That year, Ms. Werner filed a petition for a protective order, alleging that Mr. Johnson forced her to drive him to the hospital and said he was “going to cut me up and throw me in the river.” He was then involuntarily committed for mental health treatment, she wrote, adding, “Super Bowl weekend he beat me up so bad I couldn’t leave the house for days.”

She said she stayed with him until November 2012, out of a mixture of affection and fear. “Oh, my God, he could make me laugh like no other,” she said. “I wanted to save him.” But after their final fight, she found detailed notes describing her own impending death, she said. “I just realized, I can’t save this man.”

At the time, he had an apartment at Just-Inn Transition, a 42-unit apartment complex on Mount Washington. The subsidized apartments have specialized in residents with mental and physical disabilities. Mr. Johnson was evicted from there in October 2014, and on Thursday the landlord would not say why.

Advertise with us

Ms. Werner said he continued to call her, and she believed he lived at a series of hotels and hospitals.

For years, Mr. Johnson wasn’t seen much in Carnegie, until July 11, when he showed up at the police station saying he had run out of medication and wanted to go to a hospital. Officers arranged for an ambulance to take him to a hospital, said Detective Lawrence.

Ms. Werner said he never mentioned Turtle Creek Valley to her. A police source said that Mr. Johnson lived at the West Street site for some part of recent months, but records available Thursday didn’t indicate when or why he was there.

The Munhall site of Turtle Creek Valley includes two psychiatric residential programs, with fewer than 40 beds. Both were inspected by the state Department of Human Services this summer and had no violations.

Martin J. Saunders, chairman of Turtle Creek Valley’s board of directors and a labor lawyer, said the board planned to meet in the aftermath of the incident. He declined to discuss security at the facility but did note that Turtle Creek Valley wants to encourage those needing help to come into its facilities.

Advertise with us

“In dealing with the consumers and the population that we deal with, we don’t want to inhibit or discourage them from coming to seek our assistance,” Mr. Saunders said this week. “With these people, half the battle is getting them to come back and follow up on their treatment.”

Mr. Saunders referred questions to Fran Bost, executive director of community services at Turtle Creek Valley. She did not return numerous messages.

Ms. Werner speculated that Mr. Johnson arrived at Turtle Creek Valley with a plan. “Dustin was ready to go,” she said, “and was going to take people out with him.”

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com. Jonathan D. Silver and Liz Navratil contributed.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.