One of Western Pennsylvania's most notorious drug kingpins looks to be getting out of federal prison early despite initial opposition by prosecutors.
The U.S. Attorney’s office has reached an agreement with Ron Whethers, who ran one of the biggest cocaine networks on the East Coast in the 1990s and ordered a man killed.
The deal would chop his life sentence to 37 years. He will be due for release in 2033, when he will be in his mid-70s.
Whethers' lawyer, Adam Cogan, sought the reduction based on a 2014 change in sentencing guidelines that retroactively reduced time for drug offenses. The federal courts have since been flooded with reduction requests by drug dealers. Whethers has been locked up since 1996.
U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti was going to hold a hearing Monday on his request before the agreement was reached. Now, assuming she approves, she'll re-sentence him.
Mr. Cogan declined to discuss the case.
“I can’t comment on it,” he said. “It’s a pending matter before the court.”
The case is somewhat unusual in that former U.S. District Judge Robert Cindrich, who gave Whethers the life term, said in a letter to the court that he wouldn’t have done it if he wasn’t bound by mandatory federal sentencing rules.
But prosecutors initially said they were “strenuously” opposed to release, and law officers who worked on Whethers’ cases were angered that such a major crime figure would even get a hearing.
It's not clear why the prosecution backed off its original position. The U.S. Attorney’s office declined to comment.
But there’s no doubt that Whethers was among the region’s most noteworthy criminals in the 1990s.
In addition to operating a massive narcotics ring supplied from New York, his gang acted on his orders in 1993 and murdered a man whose organs were donated to the governor.
And while he was being held in the Westmoreland County Prison following his federal conviction, he continued to run his drug network with the help of smuggled cell phones and complicit guards.
That whole mess led to prosecutions of prison staff, the firing of the warden and a new state law to keep cell phones out of the hands of inmates.
Federal prosecutors Troy Rivetti and Cindy Chung also said in court papers that Whethers has been up to no good behind bars more recently, although they didn't specify what that conduct was.
Whethers, based in Fayette County, was responsible for shipping coke from New York to Western Pennsylvania and laundering the proceeds. He ruled with violence, ordering beatings for wayward gang members or anyone he thought was cooperating with authorities.
One of those beatings turned into a homicide when his cohorts beat William Lucas of Monessen in June 1993 because Whethers believed Lucas had stolen cocaine from him. Lucas died from the assault and his heart and liver were transplanted into Gov. Robert Casey in a lifesaving operation.
Whethers was sentenced in that case to 10 to 20 years to be served at the same time as his federal sentence.
“[Whethers] was the leader a conspiracy to distribute, and possess with the intent to distribute, 179 kilograms of cocaine,” prosecutors said. “Moreover, the defendant laundered vast sums of criminal proceeds and orchestrated the beatings and killings of witnesses and victims to maintain control of his empire.”
They also said he is a “unacceptable” risk to the public if let go early.
When Mr. Cogan filed his motion, the new advisory guidelines called for 360 months in prison to life. He asked for the 360 and solicited the opinion of Mr. Cindrich.
The ex-judge, who quit the bench in 2004 to join UPMC, had always chafed against mandatory sentencing guidelines because he felt that federal judges should have discretion in handling cases and that justice should not be reduced to a formula.
The guidelines are no longer mandatory, but at the time the judge had no choice but to impose a life term. If he’d had a choice, he wrote in a letter to Judge Conti, he would not have given Whethers life.
“It is very difficult to answer a hypothetical question as to what sentence I would have imposed had the law been different,” he wrote, “but it would not have been life imprisonment and certainly, 30 years of imprisonment would have been sufficient to punish the defendant, protect the public and act as a deterrent to others in my view.”
Mr. Cogan said Whethers is also a changed man after so many years in prison.
“During the decades he has spent behind bars, Whethers has evolved from the head of a major cocaine trafficking organization to a man who dedicates his time and energies to trying to better the world,” he said.
Whethers participates in a program to teach college kids what it’s like to be in prison, helped create a prison newsletter and has taken college courses.
Mr. Cogan also said Whethers won’t be a risk to anyone when he gets out, saying the prospect of freedom gives him hope.
In addition, he said it’s unfair for the U.S. Attorney’s office to say it has information about Whethers doing bad things behind bars and not reveal what it is.
“Whethers concededly was no angel and his conduct in this case warranted a very severe sentence,” Mr. Cogan said. “It did not, however, warrant a life sentence and the district judge who sentenced Whethers has concluded as such.”
Whethers didn't get the 360 months he wanted but instead agreed to 444 months, followed by 10 years of probation.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.