An attorney who owns the Iceoplex at Southpointe where the Pittsburgh Penguins formerly practiced and other nearby businesses was convicted Thursday of failure to pay quarterly payroll taxes from 2012 on, but he was acquitted on other counts from earlier years as well as an obstruction charge.
After deliberating over three days since last Friday, a federal jury found Steven Lynch, 61, a Squirrel Hill tax attorney, guilty of 16 counts of willful failure to pay payroll taxes for his workers.
The jurors found him not guilty on 11 other counts from years prior to 2012 and one charge of corrupt obstruction of the IRS, the most serious offense. All the counts are felonies. Mr. Lynch had no comment as he left the courtroom.
His lawyer, Robert Barnes, said his client had been trying to pay the taxes and had paid the IRS through the years, along with penalties and interest, although he was late.
“We’re disappointed in the verdict,” he said. “We think at all times that Mr. Lynch acted in good faith. He was just looking for time to pay.”
Mr. Barnes was at a loss to explain the jury’s decision, because the split verdict suggests that jurors believed Mr. Lynch was making an honest effort prior to 2012 but not after that year. “It makes no sense,” he said. “You can’t split good faith.”
Mr. Lynch, who owns the ice rink along with a restaurant, a gym and a real estate firm, was indicted in 2014 and prosecuted by the tax division of the Justice Department. Federal agents said he failed to withhold some $1.5 million in payroll taxes by creating a shell corporation to shield money from the IRS.
A federal grand jury said Mr. Lynch ordered his staff not pay wage tax, Social Security and Medicare contributions withheld from employee paychecks starting in 2008.
Mr. Barnes said Mr. Lynch always intended to pay but didn’t have the money after suffering losses in the 2008 recession.
He said an IRS employee had even advised him in 2010 to declare bankruptcy, but he refused because he did not want to put 120 people out of work.
U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab set sentencing for Jan. 11. Mr. Lynch remains free until then.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.