Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Anthony Mariani looked over the top of his eyeglasses at the young man standing before him, dressed in a salmon-colored Ralph Lauren button-down shirt and pleated pants.
The last time Youri Whindleton, 22, of McKeesport, stood before the judge in May, he was shackled and wearing prison orange.
But, this day, Tuesday morning, Whindleton was in court, reporting that he had used the last three months wisely: he had found a place to live, has been learning a trade, and has a lead on a job.
The judge nodded his head with satisfaction and said in a cautionary tone, "You know, you're a kind of symbol...(that puts) a little more weight on you."
The last three months have been a test period, beginning with the day that the jurist did something very different. He released Whindleton from the Allegheny County Jail.
Instead of following state sentencing guidelines and transferring him to a state prison, the judge put the young man on a special probationary program that the judge had crafted. He gave the defendant a chance to put into practice the lessons Whindleton had learned from reading a book by former presidential candidate Ben Carson, "You Have a Brain: A Teen's Guide to T.H.I.N.K. B.I.G"
Read More
Dr. Carson, a neurosurgeon, had outlined in the book how he had used his talents and his intelligence to make a successful life despite a difficult start.
Whindleton — a high school graduate who had blown a college football scholarship by getting involved with guns and drugs — had appeared before Judge Mariani in May, carrying the book in his shackled hands. He had been told in March to read the autobiography while he was in jail on a probation violation and to come back later to report on what he had learned.
The judge's decision that day in March to assign the book report followed an impassioned plea from Whindleton's attorney, James A. Wymard, who asked, “Could we find another way?” The judge recounted Tuesday for the court how Dr. Carson's book had popped into his mind. His wife had bought the book a day or so earlier for their nephew's 16th birthday.
In May, Judge Mariani was satisfied that Whindleton had gleaned some lessons from the tome and had decided to give him a chance to put the lessons into practice.
What the defendant described in court Tuesday persuaded the jurist that things were going well.
Judge Mariani commented, "We don't have many success stories, we in this building. You're doing what you said you'd do."
He warned Whindleton that the experiment won't be a real success until its longevity is proven. "It's not a success if it doesn't last," he said.
Whindleton's probation officer, Ryan Niznick, told the judge during the court session his client is "doing great." And the county probation officer commented after the hearing that he has "a good feeling" that the young man will continue on the right track. They're meeting twice a month.
Judge Mariani has sentenced several other defendants to what's been called the "book report" alternative sentencing program. In fact, he listened to a couple more reports from defendants Tuesday. Dr. Carson's publisher had provided the county with dozens of paperback versions of the book so they could be given out to defendants free of charge.
Judge Mariani said Dr. Carson and his publisher are monitoring the program. He said if the program seems successful, it could be rolled out as a national effort.
Karen Kane: kkane@post-gazette.com or at 724-772-9180.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.