White-tailed deer will be targeted in controlled archery hunts at a Scott park that is managed by Mt. Lebanon, following a court decision Friday.

Scott lost its attempt to prevent Mt. Lebanon from extending a deer-control program into Twin Hills Park, a 25-acre property fully located in Scott but purchased decades ago by Mt. Lebanon. Not recognizing political boundaries, deer routinely move from the mostly forested public park into Mt. Lebanon by crossing neighborhood streets and highways including Beverly and Cochran roads, where deer-vehicle collisions have occurred.

In October, Scott won a preliminary injunction prohibiting all hunting within Twin Hills Park. But Friday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, Judge Michael E. McCarthy determined that a 1995 deed confirms that Mt. Lebanon purchased the property from Scott with the township’s stipulation that Mt. Lebanon oversee park maintenance and operate the space for public recreation.

“Obviously we’re pleased with the decision,” said Mt. Lebanon manager Keith McGill. “The goal of the deer program is to reduce the deer population and be able to reduce the number of deer-vehicle collisions. I think the judge’s ruling recognized the danger that an overpopulation of deer presents.”

Advertise with us

Scott manager Denise Fitzgerald was unavailable for comment.

The court order permits Mt. Lebanon to conduct archery deer control in the park while setting a few conditions and forbidding other forms of management, including rifle culls and sterilization programs.

Mt. Lebanon’s 2015-2016 controlled archery hunt removed about 100 deer with no hunting-related shooting accidents. In another program held this spring, sharpshooters killed roughly 100 more with the same safety record. An attempt to launch a foundation-funded 10-year deer sterilization experiment was quashed in February, when the state Game Commission denied a request to authorize sterilization as part a special permit request.

The court order states that “having determined that an uncontrolled population of white-tailed deer present a risk to the health and safety of individuals and to the preservation of the area as a park, Mt. Lebanon does not violate the assurances given to the Scott Township Planning Commission as a condition for acquisition of the park program.”

In a controlled archery hunt, a limited number of vetted bow hunters are organized to maximize the harvest. They are considered legal hunts and not extra-regulatory culls authorized by special permits. Controlled hunts are a common component of deer management programs and have helped to reduce problem deer populations in municipalities throughout the region and at all Allegheny County parks.

Advertise with us

Among other provisions, the court order requires Mt. Lebanon to notify Scott 30 days before the start of a hunt. Mr. McGill said Twin Hills Park will not be included when nonprofit wildlife management organization White Buffalo begins its Mt. Lebanon controlled hunt on Sept. 17 on private properties. As per conditions placed on the hunt, archers have access to several Mt. Lebanon parks and the golf course Mondays through Fridays only. Twin Hills Park, said Mr. McGill, is expected to be added to the program later.

John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1991.