A 28-year-old man was ordered to stand trial in a case of double shooting that left one man dead and another wounded in Brentwood in May.

District Judge Craig Stephens ruled at a preliminary hearing in Downtown Pittsburgh today that Daevon Plowden, 28, of Brentwood, will stand trial on homicide charges in the shooting death of Tamar Taylor, 26, of Munhall, as well as the attempted killing of Daniel Jones. Mr. Plowden is also facing trial on two counts of aggravated assault, reckless endangerment, and carrying a firearm without a license.

Daevon Plowden

Mr. Plowden will argue self-defense, according to his attorney.

Advertise with us

The shooting occurred after Mr. Taylor drove Mr. Jones to Bellanca Street, where Mr. Plowden resides. Mr. Plowden's girlfriend, Lashawna Holmes, has a child with Mr. Jones. Mr. Jones, who said he was on Bellanca Street to drop off a sleeping bag, was parked across the street. As Mr. Jones stood by the car, shots were fired, leaving Mr. Taylor dead of four gunshot wounds to the trunk. Mr. Jones was also wounded in the buttock. Officers at the scene found Mr. Plowden in a wooded area.

James Wymard, Mr. Plowden's attorney, argued that his client was defending himself against Mr. Jones. During the questioning, Mr. Wymard repeatedly mentioned that Mr. Jones was barred by court order from visiting the address where the shooting occurred. Mr. Wymard referenced previous confrontations between Mr. Jones and Mr. Plowden.

According to a criminal complaint filed by police, Mr. Plowden told police that Mr. Jones had been texting Ms. Holmes, who has a protection from abuse order against him. When Mr. Jones arrived on Bellanca Street, Mr. Plowden told Mr. Jones he wasn't allowed to be at the residence because of the PFA.

During the hearing, the defense called Allegheny County homicide detective Patrick Kinavey as a witness. In an interview, Mr. Plowden told police that he had seen Mr. Jones holding a gun over the car before Mr. Plowden began to shoot. Mr. Kinavey testified that Mr. Plowden said he was in the woods because he was scared.

Mr. Jones testified that he had been getting into his car to leave, but started running down the street after Mr. Plowden started to shoot. He said that he never had a gun.

Advertise with us

Other witnesses were officer Carl Rech of the Brentwood Police Department, who was driving to the scene when he encountered Mr. Jones, and Allegheny County homicide detective Thomas Foley. Mr. Foley testified that he had found Mr. Taylor dead behind the wheel of the car and that 13 spent casings and an empty magazine were found in the street.

Assistant Allegheny District Attorney Chelsie Pratt is prosecuting the case.

Libbie Katsev: lkatsev@post-gazette.com.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.