Mt. Lebanon has continued its claim that the municipality owns a small park on its border with Scott Township, where a controlled archery deer hunt was considered last year.

Mt. Lebanon filed a motion June 2 in Common Pleas Court to end a temporary injunction that supports Scott’s claim that Mt. Lebanon has no jurisdiction over Twin Hills Park, 25 acres of undeveloped grass and woodlands at Cochran and Greentree roads within Scott’s borders.

In 1995, Mt. Lebanon purchased the tract from Scott for $1 million. Last year, when Mt. Lebanon considered including Twin Hills Park in a deer-reduction program, Scott officials opposing the program challenged the municipality’s ownership of the park.

Scott Commissioner Tom Castello said that an agreement for oversight of park maintenance, police and fire protection had never been signed, and therefore the park remained in Scott’s jurisdiction.

Advertise with us

Scott manager Denise Fitzgerald said that a Pennsylvania Game Commission special permit authorizing a deer cull applied only to the Mt. Lebanon municipality and that Scott did not want hunting in the township, citing safety concerns. In January, Scott Commissioner Bill Wells said the township had spent nearly $15,000 in legal fees challenging Mt. Lebanon’s claim of ownership.

A Game Commission spokesman, however, said hunting laws established by the state Legislature pre-empt local ordinances banning hunting, and Scott police Chief Jim Secreet concurred.

Tony DeNicola, president of White Buffalo, the nonprofit wildlife management organization hired to control Mt. Lebanon deer, said Twin Hills Park had never been included in operational plans for the controlled hunt, and that no hunting occurred there.

The controlled archery hunt eliminated about 100 deer in Mt. Lebanon in 2015-16. A Game Commission special permit is not required to hold a managed archery hunt within the archery deer seasons on private properties, including those owned by a government entities, with the owner’s permission. Another 100 Mt. Lebanon deer were later killed in a cull, which required a special permit authorizing use of non-hunting firearms, outside of hunting seasons on private property with the owner’s permission.

Citing statistical evidence of increasing deer-vehicle collisions, Mt. Lebanon commissioners set a goal of reducing those traffic accidents by 50 percent in five years.

John Hayes: 412-263-1991 or jhayes@post-gazette.com.