A resignation from the West Jefferson Hills School Board and a controversial appointment shortly after; tearful pleas from high school girls about a basketball coach and a pro-union vote on construction of the new Thomas Jefferson High School fueled Tuesday’s three-and-a-half hour special meeting of the West Jefferson Hills School Board.
After Dr. David Graham resigned for business and personal reasons after 17 years on the board, President Anthony Angotti recommended that board member Darlene Schreiber be appointed to fill the remaining two years of his term.
Mrs. Schreiber lost her bid for reelection in the recent election.
The recommendation sparked outrage among attendees like Ryan Pierce of Jefferson Hills, who called it an “underhanded move,” and said that residents should be allowed to apply and be interviewed.
The vote to appoint Mrs. Schreiber was 5 to 2, with Mr. Angotti, Alan Caponi, John Hosmer, Anna Lilley, and Carolyn Bourgeois voting yes.
The meeting began with over two hours of public comment on ongoing issues, such as a question on whether a project labor agreement (PLA) should be included in the $100 million high school construction project, and about last month’s reinstatement of suspended high school girls basketball coach Phil Shar.
Regarding the former, pro-union speakers said the PLA inclusion offers the district the benefits of higher quality work on time and on budget.
Those opposed to its inclusion said it will drive up costs, exclude local competitors, and will not guarantee a high-quality job.
The vote to advertise the request for proposals (RFP) for the project, which includes the PLA the board voted for in May, was 5 to 4, with Mr. Angotti, Mr. Caponi, Mr. Hosmer, Mrs. Lilley, and Mrs. Bourgeois voting yes.
After the meeting, R. Pete Gum, president of the Western Pennsylvania chapter of the Associated Builders and Contractors (ABC), said the PLA will keep non-union shops from bidding as 80 percent of their workers must come from the union hall, and the other 20 percent must join the union for the length of the project.
He said bids will most likely come in high due to limited competition, which may lead to changes in the RFP.
On the Shar issue, 10 girls who refuse to play basketball with Mr. Shar as coach reiterated their complaints about him, like bullying, belittling and humiliating them, being verbally and emotionally abusive.
Their parents asked that his suspension be reinstated.
Earlier, eight current team members appeared in support of Mr. Shar, with one calling him “a great coach.”
At meeting’s end, solicitor Lisa Colautti said that, according to Robert’s Rules of Order, only a board member who voted for reinstatement, but was absent for the vote, may make a motion to reconsider.
With four new board members coming aboard who would fall into the “absent” category, the motion could be made, she said.
“I hope that the new board will listen to the girls,” parent Bonnie Brock of Jefferson Hills said after the meeting.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.