Just weeks before McKeesport Area High School student Deonte Cobbs, 15, was fatally struck by a school bus in September, school district officials were having conversations with local police about where to assign crossing guards.
But even though a student had been killed in March 2014 at the same intersection where Deonte lost his life — O’Neil and Eden Park boulevards — no crossing guard was placed there when school started.
In fact, email correspondence obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette through requests under the Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law raise questions of whether the busy intersection of O’Neil and Eden Park boulevards was ever part of those conversations over the course of 18 months. But one week after Deonte’s death, a full-time guard was placed there.
On Sept. 9, 2015, officials announced plans to hire a full-time crossing guard to be stationed at the intersection for an undetermined amount of time. Board directors also hired a fencing company to install a guardrail around Eden Park and O’Neil boulevards to try to keep students from crossing outside the crosswalks.
Deonte’s death followed that of Founders Hall Middle School student Alyson Higdon, 14, who died on March 6, 2014, after she was hit by a dump truck while crossing the street near the intersection of O’Neil and Eden Park boulevards adjacent to campus.
The placement of a full-time crossing guard at the intersection was recommended by former McKeesport Councilman Paul Shelly less than a week after Alyson’s death.
Read More
On March 12, 2014, Mr. Shelly sent emails to district superintendent Rula Skezas, McKeesport Mayor Michael Cherepko and the McKeesport City Council, describing Alyson’s death as a “horrific and tragic accident.”
“It was also preventable ... there should have been a crossing guard on Eden Park Boulevard since the day Founders opened,” he wrote. “It is a miracle such a tragic accident hasn’t occurred previously.”
The email was then forwarded to assistant superintendent Harry Bauman and transportation/human resources director James Humanic by Ms. Skezas.
Mr. Shelly did not receive an official response from city or district officials, nor did he expect one, he said when reached by phone Tuesday morning.
“I really believe they have the students’ best interests at heart,” Mr. Shelly said. “Folks get a lot of things on their plate and maybe it wasn’t the priority it should’ve been then, but action has been taken now and at this point that’s the best we can hope for.”
Although emails immediately following the accident included a notice sent out to district families, faculty and staff notifying them of counseling services available to students and a 5K run to raise money for the Higdon family, a permanent crossing guard was not assigned to the intersection.
On March 25 — less than three weeks after Alyson’s death — Ms. Skezas told the Post-Gazette that the district was “evaluating the area and working along with the City of McKeesport” when asked whether a crossing guard would be assigned to the intersection. When a reporter then attempted to gain access to a district safe schools committee meeting scheduled for the following day, she consulted with former district solicitor Gary Matta to get legal advice on whether to open the meeting to the public, according to emails obtained in the request. Mr. Matta’s response was not included in email correspondence from the request.

The meeting was then abruptly canceled the night of March 25 because of “unexpected circumstances.”
The district launched a traffic safety program for primary students named for Alyson called “Aly’s Rules” in the fall of 2014. Officials discussed assigning a crossing guard at O’Neil Boulevard and Grandview Avenue — just a few blocks away from the intersection where Alyson was hit and killed — but did not discuss placing a guard at the intersection where the death occurred in the emails released to the Post-Gazette.
At the beginning of the 2015-16 school year and three weeks before Deonte’s death, four street assignments were given to district crossing guards. The intersection of O’Neil Boulevard and Eden Park Boulevard was not included in those assignments, either. The only mention of the busy intersection in the August email from Mr. Humanic to McKeesport police Chief Brian Washowich is a reference to the city repainting crosswalks around it.
Linda Croushore, executive director for the Consortium for Public Education, drives through O’Neil Boulevard on her daily commute to work. On Sept. 2, the day before Deonte was killed, she sent a complimentary email to Ms. Skezas on the district’s traffic safety measures, including police officers stationed along O’Neil and a crossing guard near the entrance of Founders Hall Middle School. There was not a crossing guard at the intersection where Alyson’s death took place, however, she noted Tuesday.
“It’s crazy that we could go from that to what happened just 24 hours later,” she said. “It’s so sad that something really tragic had to adjust the behavior of both children and adults.”
Efforts to reach Ms. Skezas and Mr. Humanic on Tuesday were unsuccessful.
Alyson’s grandmother Sharon Tarsala, 64, said she still does not understand why the district did not hire a crossing guard at the intersection after Alyson was killed there 18 months ago.
“They were basically pushed into it,” she said. “I think they dragged their feet on it, hoping it would just go away. I don’t think we’ll ever fully know what they were thinking.”
Clarece Polke: cpolke@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1889.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.