A federal magistrate on Thursday ruled that a Mt. Lebanon man serving a life term for a 2002 drug-related murder will get a new trial because his trial lawyer was not effective.

In ruling in Jared Henkel's habeas petition filed in April, U.S. Magistrate Judge Robert Mitchell said Henkel's lawyer was ineffective in that he didn't have Henkel testify or prepare him to testify at the trial in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.

A jury convicted Henkel and Jared Lischner of second-degree murder in the killing of Andrew Jones, a drug dealer from Ridgemont. Another man, Craig Elias, was convicted of first-degree murder.

Prosecutors said the three men, all Mt. Lebanon High School classmates, kidnapped and killed Jones and then dumped his body in the Ohio River after weighing it down with chains and a barbell plate.

Advertise with us

All received life in prison.

Lischner also had argued that his lawyer was ineffective and in 2012 won a new trial under the Post-Conviction Relief Act. He later pleaded guilty to third-degree murder and is serving a 10-to-20-year term.

Elias's appeal is pending.

Prosecutors said the three men killed Jones because they believed he had broken into their stash house on Mount Washington and stole safes containing cocaine and cash.