Munhall Councilman Bernie Shields said he had decided to resign because he had had enough of dealing with problems in the borough government — and that was before he went heels over head in council chambers Wednesday night after a colleague got into a heated exchange with him.
According to witnesses, Councilman Joseph Ballas confronted Mr. Shields, grabbed him around the neck and pushed him backward over his chair.
“He was in my face,” Mr. Shields said, “and then he just grabbed me by my throat and pushed me back.”
Mr. Ballas could not be reached for comment Thursday afternoon.
The incident has Mr. Shields calling for the immediate resignation of Mr. Ballas, whose term ends in January because he lost his seat in the May 19 primary. That election, Mr. Shields said, was where the trouble started.
Mr. Ballas placed sixth out of 10 candidates vying for three spots in the primary. Mr. Shields won re-election but decided to step down instead of serving another term.
Mr. Ballas went before the Munhall Democratic Committee — which Mr. Shields serves as chairman — and asked to be picked to fill the open position, according to Mr. Shields. Instead, the committee chose Jason Stein, who placed fourth in the primary.
The committee’s decision upset Mr. Ballas, according to Councilman Rick Brennan, who, along with Mr. Shields, supported Mr. Stein for the open seat.
“He came up to both of us [after the meeting] because he knew that both of us were involved in helping Jason Stein,” Mr. Brennan said.
Mr. Shields happened to speak first when confronted, and that’s why Mr. Ballas went after him, Mr. Brennan said.
“Ballas proceeded to taunt him,” Mr. Brennan said. “He grabbed him by the throat and asked him to get in a fight with him … I told [Mr. Ballas] to calm down and that this was really not appropriate.”
The two men had to be separated.
Munhall police Chief Patrick Campbell, who was at the meeting but said he did not see the fight, escorted the councilmen out of the chambers and took them to the police station.
Mr. Shields said that Mr. Ballas apologized to him. He said he did not pursue charges because “pressing charges drags the borough through the mud.”
The chief said the incident was unusual.
“There’s been some heated discussions. Luckily it’s not the norm. This was a very rare occurrence from what I’ve seen in 11 years attending council meetings.”
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.