The Allegheny County district attorney's office today said one of its detectives was justified in filing criminal complaints in two cases against a part-time Whitaker police officer who was later acquitted.
In response to a federal civil rights suit brought last year by Officer William Davis against District Attorney Stephen Zappala, his office and one of his detectives, Lyle Graber, the DA's office said Det. Graber had probable cause to charge Officer Davis.
The office also said it and Det. Graber are immune to claims of malicious prosecution for duties they carried out in official capacity.
Officer Davis, 38, was acquitted on charges that he lied repeatedly in a 2012 search warrant affidavit for two addresses where he thought drug activity was going on and in a second case in 2012 in which he was charged with extorting a young woman after a traffic stop near the Rankin Bridge.
In the traffic stop incident, the woman, Danielle Newlon, said Officer Davis pulled her over on June 27 in an unmarked car, but because he was wearing a t-shirt and shorts, she drove away while calling 911.
When she pulled over again near Kennywood Park, she said Officer Davis approached with his gun drawn and told her to roll down the window.
She said he smashed the window with his gun, damaging it, then filed charges against when she refused to pay to have the gun fixed. The woman also said Officer Davis had sexually harassed her, saying she might have gotten glass in her vagina when he smashed the window and telling her she "looked phenomenal" and would have no trouble "working the streets" to raise money to pay for the gun.
She reported the incident to the DA's office, which filed charges against Officer Davis.
In its response to the suit, the DA's office also said the Whitaker police chief had told Det. Graber that Officer Davis had made other questionable traffic stops.
The district attorney's office had also charged Officer Davis in a second case in which another woman, Michele Lang, said he filed bogus search warrants and then seized her car, arrested her and took custody of her son. The DA's office said Officer Davis illegally seized the car, a TV, a game station and speakers.
A jury found Officer Davis not guilty on all counts, but the DA's office said Det. Graber clearly had sufficient evidence to charge him in both cases.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.