Federal prosecutors said Friday they will retry Jason Korey on weapons charges after a judge declared a mistrial the day before when the jury deadlocked.
Korey, 32, of Baldwin Borough, who has twice been acquitted of homicides, went on trial last week before Chief U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti on charges of possessing a stolen gun and ammunition as a convicted felon.
The jurors began deliberating Wednesday and spent all day in deliberations Thursday before telling the judge they couldn’t reach a decision.
The U.S. Attorney’s office would not comment on the case, but prosecutors filed a motion Friday indicating they will make another attempt.
The case is noteworthy because police and the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives have tried repeatedly to put Korey behind bars since he was a teenager with numerous prosecutions in state and federal courts, but with little success.
In addition to the two homicides in the 1990s in which he was acquitted, charges of attempting a third were withdrawn, a federal weapons sentence of 33 years was reduced to 33 months and a second federal indictment brought in 2008 was thrown out.
In the latest federal case, prosecutors said authorities found a .40-caliber handgun and ammo during an April 17, 2014, search of his mother’s house following an investigation by his federal probation officer.
Government witness Amy Koza, testifying under a grant of immunity, said that a few months before the search, she drove Korey and his friend Ryan Murtaugh in Korey’s mother's car to a drug dealer’s house to burglarize it.
The pistol was among the items stolen. The government said Korey kept the gun at his mother’s house among a pile of his belongings in the basement room where he and his girlfriend lived.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Cindy Chung told jurors during her closing argument Wednesday that their decision is simple: Korey is a convicted felon and can’t have guns, but he had one.
But James Kraus, Korey’s lawyer, argued that the government’s witnesses are unreliable drug addicts and that there is little evidence to support the prosecution theory that the stolen gun belonged to Korey. Neither his fingerprints nor his DNA was found on it.
In his statement to the jury at the beginning of the trial, he also pointed the finger at Murtaugh as the gun owner because he said Murtaugh was part of the burglary and had lived for a time with Korey at his mother’s house.
But during the trial, as the government pointed out, he never returned to that contention.
Law enforcement officers have been keeping a close eye on the case because of Korey’s past.
A county jury acquitted him of killing Joseph Brucker, 17, of Whitehall in 1998, and a judge acquitted him of killing William Kuhn III, 24, of the South Side Slopes in 2000.
A third case in which he was accused of attempted homicide was withdrawn because the victim would not testify.
Korey has also appeared repeatedly in federal court as prosecutors sought to put him in prison on gun charges in connection with one of the earlier killings.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.