Edward McDonald — who admitted to lighting a six-alarm fire last week that destroyed a historic section of Homestead — was “unusually happy and cheerful” days after the blaze and could not explain the charges against him or why he was being held in jail, a psychiatrist told an Allegheny County judge Thursday.

Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning ruled that McDonald, 27, was not competent to stand trial and will be sent for treatment at Torrance State Hospital in Westmoreland County for up to 60 days.

Tushar Makadia, a psychiatrist with Allegheny County’s Behavioral Assessment Unit, told Judge Manning he met with McDonald on Monday and diagnosed the man with unspecified schizophrenia and likely bipolar disorder.

McDonald was easily distracted, couldn’t respond to questions, and was disheveled and unkempt, Dr. Makadia said. He looked around the room while they talked and was probably experiencing auditory or other hallucinations, the doctor said.

Advertise with us

“He couldn’t explain or provide a reason for being there,” said Dr. Makadia, who recommended McDonald be transferred to Torrance.

McDonald told federal agents Jan. 23 he had started the blaze about 4:30 that morning in his apartment above Concept Uniform on East Eighth Avenue. The fire gutted and damaged buildings in Homestead’s main commercial district, displaced tenants and sent two people to the hospital.

Police estimated the fire caused more than $2 million in damage and charged McDonald with 14 felony counts of arson and a felony charge of risking a catastrophe. He was being held in the Allegheny County Jail in lieu of $100,000 bail.

Two days before the fire, McDonald told neighbors he was depressed, hearing voices and worried about the end of the world, according to a criminal complaint. He also sought mental health treatment days before the fire, police said.

Pleasant Hills police arrested McDonald on Christmas Day 2007, after they said they saw him speeding in a stolen car in which they found marijuana and plastic bags containing narcotics.

Advertise with us

He later pleaded guilty to unauthorized use of a vehicle and speeding, and the drug charges were withdrawn. When he entered that plea, he signed a standard form used in other cases.

One of the dozens of questions people must answer when entering a guilty plea is, “Have you ever had any physical or mental illness that would affect your ability to understand these rights or affect the voluntary nature of your plea?”

Someone put an “X” in the spot to indicate yes, then scribbled it out and crossed off the “No” box. The change was signed with the initials “EM.”