Mt. Lebanon residents concerned about the safety and cost of an artificial turf soccer field have a message for the Mt. Lebanon Commission: Recede and reseed.

That is, recede from the decision to use artificial turf and instead reseed it with natural grass seed. Artificial turf is made from old tires, which concerns residents because they contain carcinogens, lead, zinc and other potentially harmful ingredients that could get into the air and water.

“There have been various studies done, very broad based, very general, and they all say at the very end that there is no proven fact of whether they are harmful or non-harmful to humans,” said Kelly Fraasch, Mt. Lebanon Ward 5 commissioner. “So until we get those answers it is important for us to be cautious.”

Ms. Fraasch, the lone Mt. Lebanon commissioner to vote against the use of artificial turf, was one of the speakers at a rally Sunday morning near the field in Mt. Lebanon’s Main Park where about 50 concerned Mt. Lebanon residents protested the installation of the artificial turf. Rally organizers also called on the community to attend the commission meeting at 8 tonight in the municipal building on Washington Road.

Advertise with us

Much of the concern came after a recent story on NBC News that correlated artificial turf with cancer in soccer players, particularly in goalkeepers who spend the most time on the turf.

But David Brumfield, Mt. Lebanon Ward 4 commissioner, said the NBC report used anecdotal evidence from what some soccer players may have thought caused their cancer in place of actual scientific evidence. He also said that football players spend more time than anyone on turf, and there have been no complaints about the artificial turf used at the Mt. Lebanon High School football field. He said the artificial turf will increase the number of events and time of year the field can be used.

The commission has seen some studies and brought in experts to question about the safety of the turf. Residents, though, said they feel as if the commission is putting a spin on the facts.

“The Mt. Lebanon Public Information Office hired an expert to speak on the positives,” Mt. Lebanon resident Jeff Heiskell said, adding that the possible negative affects were largely ignored.

Residents also believe that the money being used to finance the field, $750,000 from the municipality, could go to better use in the community’s schools or infrastructure. Mr. Brumfield said the turf won’t come out of already budgeted costs and won’t cause any tax increase.

Advertise with us

Still, parents and neighbors say the field is not worth any potential health risk and the money could be better spent elsewhere.

“They have confused the wants of a few with the needs of many,” said Jason Margolis, co-organizer of the rally.