A day after former state Sen. Jane Orie was sent to state prison following her conviction on charges she used her staff for political campaigns, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said it was likely her effort to cover her crimes that led the judge to sentence her to time behind bars.
Monday, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning ordered her to state prison for 21/2 to 10 years on public corruption charges.
"You're talking ... tampering with documents, tampering with evidence, things like that," Mr. Zappala said Tuesday, offering brief comments for the first time since Orie was sent to prison. "Those are pretty serious crimes."
Orie, who resigned her seat representing McCandless last month, was convicted in March of multiple counts of theft of services, conflict of interest, ethics violations, tampering with evidence and forgery, and a single count of conspiracy. Her initial trial ended in mistrial in February 2011, when prosecutors accused her of submitting fraudulent documents into evidence. She was retried this year, with prosecutors adding charges for the forged evidence.
Mr. Zappala was adamant that the sentence was appropriate but said it was likely the document forgery and evidence tampering that led Judge Manning to decide on jail time, instead of a lesser punishment.
"It was fraud perpetrated on the court," he said. "I think that made a big difference."
Mr. Zappala also responded to criticism that his prosecution was motivated by a feud between the two judicially and politically connected families. Orie has contended she was targeted because of her opposition to a casino in which Mr. Zappala's uncle was involved and because of her criticism of the Pennsylvania Casino Association, where his father, Stephen Zappala Sr., is a member.
"The use of the term 'vendetta' was intended to be an ethnic slur," Mr. Zappala said, suggesting that the Orie family framed the prosecution this way because his family is Italian.
But, he said, "this isn't a political campaign," he said. "When you try and mislead the public, you're going to have to go to court and you're going to have to prove your case."
In an email from his spokesman Mike Manko, Mr. Zappala countered that Orie voted for Senate Bill 711, which would have authorized table games in the commonwealth, in July 2009 and even served as a sponsor on the original bill.
But ultimately, Orie opposed table games, voting against the final bill in January 2010. The original bill that bore her name did not permit table games.
Still, Mr. Zappala reiterated that he had no animosity toward the Orie family, nor toward Orie herself.
"First, with respect to their being any sort of [animus] from Steve to the Orie family, the only time he can remember having a lengthy conversation with Jane is when she called here to ask that her brother [Jerry], who was working here at the time, be given a raise," Mr. Manko wrote. "As Steve recalls, the raise was granted following the conversation."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.