Three Republican candidates with similar opinions but vastly different backgrounds debated in Peters on Tuesday in the race for the 37th state Senate District seat.
State Sen. John Pippy, R-Moon, is not seeking re-election, and the winner of the seat likely will be chosen during the April 24 primary election because no Democrats have filed.
The district includes the Pittsburgh International Airport corridor and parts of the South Hills (Bethel Park, Jefferson Hills, Mt. Lebanon, Pleasant Hills, South Fayette, South Park, Upper St. Clair and Whitehall) in Allegheny County, along with Peters in Washington County.
Sponsored by the Peters Township Republican Committee, the debate was televised and attended by about 50 people. It included D. Raja, 46, a business executive and former Mt. Lebanon commissioner; state Rep. Mark Mustio, R-Moon, 54, an insurance company president who represents the 44th Legislative District; and Sue Means, 60, a nurse from Bethel Park.
Though there were tense moments among them at times during the two-hour debate at the Peters Township Middle School, Mr. Raja and Mr. Mustio didn't touch much on their battle over the airwaves.
In a television ad that has been running since late last month, Mr. Mustio's campaign has accused Mr. Raja of outsourcing jobs to his native India and features an image of Mr. Raja with the Indian flag superimposed in the background.
During his opening statements in the debate, Mr. Raja said he came to America 25 years ago to attend the University of Pittsburgh and founded a successful software company in the spare bedroom of his Scott townhouse.
Today, Mr. Raja said his company is still based in Scott and employs 400 people, with 80 to 100 of those in India, and about 94 percent of the firm's money is spent locally.
Mr. Raja's campaign has an ad slamming Mr. Mustio for voting in favor of the 2005 pay raise and for taking taxpayer-funded per diems and other perks as a legislator.
During the debate, Mr. Mustio said he regretted voting for the pay raise and said he returned the money.
Mrs. Means kept her focus on what she sees as a bloated state government that needs to be kept on a strict spending diet.
"Our state is sick," she said. "Our government is infected with parasites."
The candidates agreed that the state is business unfriendly and needs to promote job growth and investment with a fairer and more predictable tax structure.
"We have the second highest business tax in the country," Mr. Raja said. "Our regulations are archaic."
Each of the candidates also said they stood behind prevailing wage reforms that could save local governments and school districts millions in construction projects.
The candidates differed on their approach to term limits and downsizing government, with Mr. Mustio backing a measure passed last week that would shrink the size of the General Assembly by 62 seats.
"That means we're taking a look at ourselves first," said Mr. Mustio, who is seeking a sixth term in the 44th District, along with his run for the Senate seat.
Mrs. Means disagreed, saying such a move would give more power to fewer people.
"I believe in term limits," she said. "Citizens volunteering for duty, not career politicians who are worried about getting re-elected."
Mr. Raja said he would "lead by example" by not accepting a taxpayer-funded pension. Instead, he favors the introduction of a 401(k) retirement plan for state employees.
"We need to move from a defined benefit to a defined contribution," he said of pensions. "Elected officials have to lead."
The candidates varied on their views about privatization and funding for liquor stores, state-owned roads and public transportation, with each favoring some form of public-private partnership.
"I think public transportation should be privatized," said Mrs. Means, who described the Port Authority of Allegheny County as "broken" and in need of reorganization.
Mr. Raja and Mr. Mustio, however, said they supported a government role in public transportation, especially for the poor and elderly, though they would prefer public-private partnerships to address long-term funding needs.
"We do have a need for mass transit," said Mr. Mustio, who described the Port Authority as a "beast."
Mr. Mustio said he would favor privatizing the Pennsylvania Turnpike as a possible transit funding solution, but Mr. Raja said he would like to avoid new taxes and fees for commuters if possible.
The candidates generally agreed on their views about public education funding, each expressing support for a ban on teacher strikes.
"The teachers have parents and kids over a barrel," while they negotiate unreasonable contracts, said Mrs. Means, who also favored an easier system for teacher furloughs.
Mr. Mustio said he would like to see an amendment to arbitration laws along with a strike ban and more school choice options.
"Competition is good for our schools," he said.
Property tax reform was also a consistent theme, with each candidate favoring a moratorium being considered by lawmakers, to require statewide reassessments instead of the current system of countywide reassessments.
"It's unconstitutional to have property tax," said Mrs. Means, who prefers higher sales tax to generate revenue.
Mr. Raja pointed out that the uncertainty surrounding assessments isn't conductive to creating jobs and business opportunities.
"Having a fluctuating system like this doesn't work," he said.
To address corruption in the Legislature, the candidates said it's important to find people who want to serve for the right reasons.
"It's hard for me to go to Harrisburg and see what happens to some of the people there," Mr. Mustio said. "I wanted to step up to the plate and help, and I did."
"You've got to have people who go there to give back," Mr. Raja said. "This isn't a career for me. I don't need a job."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.