Owners of about two dozen Habitat for Humanity houses in some of Allegheny County's poorest municipalities are facing new property assessments that have more than doubled.
Maggie Withrow, executive director of the Greater Pittsburgh chapter of the nonprofit organization, said the new, higher real estate values contradict the results of recent private appraisals, which showed modest gains at best in places such as Braddock, North Braddock and Duquesne.
She pointed to a Habitat-renovated home owned by a low-income family on Corey Avenue in Braddock. Its current assessment is $38,200, but county assessors revalued it for 2013 at $110,100, an increase of 188 percent. The new assessment compares to a 2010 property appraisal of just $32,000.
"It is not feasible that the house could have gained so much in two years," Ms. Withrow said.
Justin Ackerman, a lawyer on Habitat's volunteer board, and his law firm, Babst Calland, have agreed to represent Habitat families who want to appeal their new values at no cost.
"We're not asking that these homeowners be treated differently," Mr. Ackerman said. "We want to have their reassessed values reflect market values."
About 20 families thus far have requested representation from Babst Calland. Property owners have until Monday to appeal their new assessments, which will go into effect in 2013.
Since 1986, Habitat of Greater Pittsburgh has renovated or built houses for 71 families in a dozen different city neighborhoods and suburban communities. Mr. Ackerman said that about one-third show evidence of being overassessed.
Families selected for the program must provide a minimum of 350 hours of labor, or "sweat equity," to qualify. They also must have income between 30 percent and 60 percent of the $64,900 mean income for the region. For the Pittsburgh area, those numbers are between $19,450 and $38,900 for a family of four.
Client families then receive 30-year, no-interest mortgages with a portion of their monthly payments going toward taxes and insurance.
If the new higher assessments are upheld, monthly payments would remain level, but the term of the mortgage would be extended as less money became available to pay down principal, Ms. Withrow said. A family that already had made several years' worth of monthly payments on a 30-year mortgage could find themselves back at the starting line, she said.
A large increase in assessed value, however, is not proof of an incorrect property valuation. Some of the places where Habitat families live have seen significant increases in property values since 2002 when the last countywide reassessment took place, Ms. Withrow and Mr. Ackerman said.
The new value on one client family's home in Westwood rose from $99,500 to $128,800, but that number reflects selling prices for similar properties in that neighborhood, they said.
An even more dramatic assessment increase in the Hill District -- from $45,900 to $120,600 -- also is likely accurate in that it reflects current market prices in a neighborhood that is improving, Ms. Withrow said.
That day has not arrived yet in Duquesne, Mr. Ackerman said. "I wish it were, but that day is not today," he said.
Babst Calland will file challenges by the April 2 deadline for all Habitat clients who wished to make formal appeals, but lawyers then would review each case to determine the likely success of an appeal.
"We're committed to supporting many of the community activities in which our lawyers are involved," Babst Calland managing shareholder Chester R. Babst III said. "On this matter, we're supporting Justin Ackerman's leadership in the community and in the firm for helping to make sure justice is served for those who are underrepresented."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.